10 Best Chewy Cat Food Picks 2023: Which Will You Choose?

We all want to give our feline friends the best nutrition possible. With so many cat food options available on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. Whether you have a picky eater, a cat with special dietary needs, or just want to provide a variety of flavors, Chewy has an extensive selection of cat food that can cater to all of your cat's needs.

After researching the options available on Chewy, I’ve come up with the best cat food picks that offer high-quality ingredients, a range of flavors, and cater to various dietary needs. The options range from wet food to dry food, and each is crafted to provide essential nutrients to help your cat maintain overall health. Every option contains the recommended amount of taurine, which is essential for a cat’s development.

My top recommendation is the Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack. This canned cat food is made with high-quality ingredients, featuring tender cuts of grilled seafood infused with a savory broth. Let’s take a look at all the options that made it onto my list.

The Best Chewy Cat Food Picks Meals Reviewed

1. Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood – Best Overall Cat Food Brand on Chewy

Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack Canned Cat Food is a popular cat food made with high-quality ingredients and provides balanced and complete nutrition for cats of all ages. This is useful if you have more than 1 cat at different life stages.

This variety pack includes 3 different flavors: Grilled Tuna Feast in Gravy, Grilled Salmon Feast in Gravy, and Grilled Seafood Feast in Gravy. Each can contains a savory blend of real seafood that’s cooked to perfection and then simmered in a rich gravy to enhance the flavor and texture.

It’s made with real fish and seafood, providing a rich source of protein and other essential nutrients that help to support your cat's overall health and well-being. This cat food is also free from any artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, ensuring that your cat is only consuming natural and wholesome ingredients.

The cans are easy to open and serve, making mealtime quick and convenient for both you and your cat. The Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack Canned Cat Food is a great choice for cats who love seafood and is sure to be a hit with even the most finicky eaters.

I really appreciate being able to rotate between different flavors. This will definitely keep your cats interested and satisfied. For the best value, choose the case of 24t, which currently retails at $0.28/oz.

2. Friskies Shreds in Gravy – Best Low-Calorie Cat Food on Chewy

Friskies Shreds Variety Pack Canned Cat Food is a popular and affordable option for cat owners looking to provide their feline friends with a balanced and delicious meal.

This variety pack includes 40 cans, with 10 cans of each of the 4 flavors: Turkey & Cheese, Beef, Ocean Whitefish & Tuna, and Chicken & Salmon. Each can contains 5.5 ounces of food.

Each can features tender shreds of real meat in a savory gravy, providing a satisfying texture for cats to enjoy. This also makes the food easy for your cat to digest.

The meat and fish used in this cat food are high-quality sources of protein, which is essential for maintaining your cat's muscle mass and overall health. Additionally, the gravy in each meal helps to keep your cat hydrated, which is important for urinary tract health.

It’s free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives, ensuring that your cat is only consuming natural and wholesome ingredients. The cans are easy to open and serve, making mealtime quick and convenient for both you and your cat.

Some reviews have mentioned that the food is a bit on the watery side, but most report that their cats still enjoy it and lick their plates clean. Unfortunately, the Turkey & Cheese option is not suitable for kittens. If you have cats at different life stages, I recommend the Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack instead.

The price point for this variety pack is attractive compared to other wet food options on the market, making it an affordable option. The current price works out at only $0.14/oz.

3. Purina Friskies Seafood & Chicken Pate – Best Value Pate Cat Food on Chewy

This is a great value variety pack of wet cat food that your furry friend will love. The Purina Friskies Seafood & Chicken Pate Favorites pack is an excellent option and is a great choice for your adult cats. Each case comes with 40 5.5-ounce cans of food in different flavors, such as chicken, tuna, and salmon.

It's made with high-quality protein sources and essential nutrients, ensuring your cat receives a well-balanced diet. You'll appreciate that the cans are easy to store, and the variety pack ensures your cat won't get bored with their food.

Many customers report that their cats enjoy the smooth and creamy pate texture, which is easy to eat and digest. This makes it a good option to try with your senior cat or if your cat has digestive issues.

Some customers mention that the food has a strong odor, but most find that their cats really enjoy it and find it to be a tasty and nutritious meal.

It’s currently available at a retail price of $0.14/oz. If your cat isn’t keen on pate textures, you could try a shredded texture instead. I’d opt for the Friskies Shreds to switch things up a bit for your cat.

4. Fancy Feast Savory Centers – Best Chewy Cat Food for Senior Cats

Fancy Feast Savory Centers is an ideal option for senior cats. The moisture from the real broth in every bite helps to keep your pal hydrated, which is especially important for senior cats or cats with urinary tract issues.

This variety pack features 24 cans of purr-worthy pate in 4 different recipes: salmon, tuna, chicken, or beef, offering your cat the variety she craves. Each can is made with high-quality ingredients, which gives your cat complete and balanced meals.

The double textures of these recipes offer a smooth, light pate with a thick, meaty gravy and a hidden center in each can, giving your cat a unique and tasty dining experience.

It also contains all the vitamins and minerals needed to support your cat's overall health. You can feel good knowing that your cat is getting the essential nutrients she needs to thrive.

It is a good option for cats with allergies as all recipes are grain free. It could even help to improve your cats' digestive issues.

Customers rave about how much their cats enjoy the flavor and texture of this cat food, and many report that their cats are excited at mealtime. The gravy center is a unique gourmet feature that many cats seem to love, and the variety pack ensures that your cat won't get bored with the same flavor.

This is a gourmet cat food option with a price to match. At the time of writing, it retails at $0.41/oz. If you don’t need a grain-free recipe, you could try out the more affordable Purina Friskies instead.

5. Fancy Feast Classic Seafood Feast – Best Chewy Cat Food for Kittens

This option is worth considering if you're in search of a grain-free cat food option that’s made without artificial colors or preservatives.

This variety pack includes 24 cans of wet cat food, each containing 3 ounces of high-quality ingredients for a complete and balanced diet that your cat will love.

The variety pack features a range of delicious seafood-based flavors, including cod, sole and shrimp, savory salmon, and ocean whitefish and tuna, all of which are listed as the first ingredient.

The smooth, soft pate texture is paired with a savory cat food gravy that adds to the deliciousness of the meal.

This wet cat food tastes delicious and delivers all the essential vitamins and minerals to support your best friend’s overall health. Plus, as the food is free of grains and artificial colors or preservatives, it's a great option for cats with food sensitivities.

The small size of the cans makes them easy to store and serve, and this also means you can tempt your cat with a different flavor at every mealtime. However, if you have more than one cat, a bigger sized tin like the Purina Friskies pate recipes might be more convenient. This food currently retails at $0.27/oz.

6. Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef – Best Fish-Free Cat Food on Chewy

Choosing a cat food that doesn't contain fish can be beneficial for many cats, especially those with sensitive stomachs or skin allergies. The Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef Feast Variety Pack is a great alternative.

This variety pack is full of essential vitamins and minerals to keep your cat's overall health in tip-top shape. Your feline friend will enjoy the chicken, turkey, and beef flavors.

The bite-sized meaty pieces are gently cooked and served in a thick, mouthwatering gravy that’ll have your cat licking their dish clean every time. And with an even mix of Turkey Feast, Chicken Feast, and Beef Feast, it’s perfect for cats who aren’t fans of fish.

This cat food also provides 100% complete nutrition with every serving, ensuring that your cat gets all the essential vitamins, minerals, and taurine they need. And with a tempting texture that your cat will come back to every time, you can show your feline friend just how much they mean to you.

This food is currently available at a price of $0.28/oz. It doesn’t have any added Omegas, which you might prefer to have. If you want the benefit of these, I recommend the Friskies Shreds instead.

7. Friskies Surfin’ & Turfin’ Favorites – Best Low-Calorie Cat Food on Chewy

The Purina Friskies recipes are low in calories. This makes it a great option if your furry friend is overweight. Feeding your adult cat a low-calorie diet can help them lose weight or maintain a healthy weight, which can improve their overall health and well-being.

This variety pack of wet cat food will tantalize your feline friend's taste buds. The Purina Friskies Wet Cat Food Variety Pack, Surfin' & Turfin' Prime Filets Favorites contains 40 cans of mouth-watering meals for your mini mate, making it purr-fect for keeping your cat's mealtime exciting and varied.

Each 5.5-ounce can of this high-protein wet cat food is convenient and easy to serve, making mealtime a breeze. Plus, each meal is prepared to provide 100% complete and balanced nutrition to keep your adult cat happy and healthy.

The pack features shredded chunks of poultry, meat, or fish and savory gravy or juice, providing a tempting texture and irresistible flavors that your feline friend will love. If your cat isn’t a fan of the chunky texture, I recommend Purina Friskies which is a similarly priced pate recipe.

This pack includes 4 different recipes that your cat is sure to enjoy: Ocean Whitefish & Tuna, Salmon & Beef, Chicken & Tuna, and Beef & Chicken. Each recipe is crafted with essential vitamins and minerals to support your cat's overall health and wellness. It’s currently priced at $0.15/oz making it an affordable option.

8. Fancy Feast Delights with Cheddar – Best Cat Food Topper Option

Treat your finicky feline to a dining experience fit for a queen with Fancy Feast Delights with Cheddar Grilled Variety Pack Canned Cat Food. You can even mix it with dry food for a unique texture that your cat will love.

This collection of high-quality cat food is infused with aged cheddar cheese and is slow-cooked to provide your adult cat with an irresistible taste sensation. With 3 different grilled meat flavors, including chicken, turkey, and whitefish, this variety pack is sure to keep your cat's taste buds entertained and satisfied.

Recipes are made in the US and each entrée offers complete nutrition to support and maintain your adult cat's optimum health. And with the handy flip-top designed can, serving this delicious cat food has never been easier.

Your cat will love the delectable flavors and tender texture, and you'll love knowing that you're giving her the best. Plus, this cat food provides a great way to add moisture to your cat's diet, which is essential for maintaining healthy kidneys and preventing urinary tract issues.

This currently retails at $0.28/oz, so isn’t a budget recipe. Some customers have reported their cats aren’t a fan of the cheesy recipes. If you’re looking for a more meat-based option, I’d try the Fancy Feast Grilled recipe instead which has a similar texture.

9. Purina Cat Chow Naturals – Highest Protein Dry Food on Chewy

This is the only dry food recipe on my list, and it’s packed with protein. A diet high in protein helps cats feel full and satisfied, which can prevent overeating and contribute to maintaining a healthy weight. It’s best suited for high-protein, weight-control, and indoor cat diets.

This dry cat food provides natural nutrition for your furry friend. Purina Cat Chow Naturals Original with Added Vitamins, Minerals & Nutrients is a dry cat food made with top-quality ingredients including real chicken as the primary ingredient.

This cat food is formulated for all life stages and contains salmon along with whole grains for a taste your cat will love.

It also includes hairball control to help prevent those pesky hairballs. With 25 important vitamins and minerals and omega-6, this recipe supports your cat’s skin and keeps its coat healthy. This cat food delivers 100% balanced and complete nutrition in every meal.

You can trust that this Purina recipe is backed by high-quality nutritional standards and food safety requirements. Plus, it doesn't contain any artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, which means you can feel good about serving it to your adult cat.

It’s currently available on Chewy at $1.38/lb. If your cat isn’t a fan of dry food, you could serve it as a snack instead. Or try a pate textured cat food like Purina Friskies.

10. Friskies Classic Pate Variety Pack – Best Cat Food for All Life Stages

The Friskies Classic Pate Variety Pack is a good option for all life stages of cats because it provides complete and balanced nutrition that meets the dietary needs of cats at different stages of life. The formula is made with real meat, which provides high-quality protein for muscle maintenance and growth, essential for kittens and adult cats alike.

The pack includes 24 5.5-ounce cans of favorite recipes, each featuring real meat including chicken, tuna, and turkey in a savory sauce.

These high-protein meals are perfect for satisfying your little carnivore's natural cravings, and the included vitamins and mineral complex help support their overall health and vitality.

One of the key ingredients in this cat food is essential taurine, which plays an important role in maintaining heart and eye health. And with its complete and balanced formula, this cat food provides all the nutrients your cat needs to stay healthy, whether you serve it on its own or as a topper for your cat’s current kibble.

Plus, because the pate is made with real broth, it also helps keep your cat hydrated and supports urinary health.

This Friskies cat food is crafted with love in US facilities, so you can feel good about serving it to your furry friend. Simply open up the easy pull tab and turn mealtime into yum time for your feline companion. At the time of writing, it retails at an affordable $0.15/oz.

Quick Comparison Table

FAQ

What types of cat food are available on Chewy?

Chewy offers a wide variety of cat foods, including dry food, wet food, raw food, freeze-dried food, and dehydrated food. There are also foods suitable for a range of nutritional needs, such as high-protein diets and grain-free options.

How do I know which cat food is best for my cat?

The best cat food for your cat depends on their age, weight, health condition, and dietary preferences. It's always a good idea to consult with your veterinarian to determine the most appropriate diet for your cat. Your cat might prefer a particular texture of food such as pate recipes or chunks in gravy.

What is the difference between regular cat food and grain-free cat food?

Regular cat food has grains like wheat, corn, and rice, which can provide carbs and energy for cats. Grain-free cat food doesn't have these grains and might be better for cats with food sensitivities or allergies.