ButcherBox Review 2025: Meat Lovers' Choice
ButcherBox offers high-quality, sustainably sourced beef, pork, chicken, and seafood. You can choose between the Curated Plan, where ButcherBox selects the cuts, or the Custom Plan, which allows full control over the box contents and is more expensive. However, seafood is only available as part of the Custom Plan, which is disappointing if you’re on a budget.
The meat quality is exceptional. Beef is grass-fed, grass-finished, and sourced from Australia, ensuring a richer flavor. Pork comes from hormone-free heritage breeds, and chicken is organic, free-range, and antibiotic-free. The seafood selection includes wild-caught options like salmon and cod.
Orders arrive frozen in recyclable packaging with dry ice for freshness. Make sure you have enough freezer space before ordering, as all items must be placed in the freezer after unboxing. While the use of shrink-wrapped plastic isn’t great for the environment, it ensures food safety. ButcherBox also offers recipes and guides to help you prepare its premium ingredients with confidence.
Shipping is free across the continental US, and you’ll be able to choose between the Classic Box or Big Box, depending on your needs. Using your online account, you can easily manage your subscription, box contents, and the frequency of deliveries.
Though ButcherBox’s prices are high, they reflect the quality and ethical sourcing of its products. The service is ideal for omnivores, high-protein diets, and keto or paleo lifestyles. For those seeking premium, humanely sourced meats, I think it’s a reliable and convenient option.
pros
Humanely and ethically sourced productsAccess to a range of high-quality cutsSuppliers that use sustainable practicescons
Bulk meat takes a lot of freezer spaceYou need to plan your deliveries aheadUses a lot of plastic packagingButcherBox’s Menu: Good Variety of Fine Meats
ButcherBox’s meat delivery menu includes many different cuts of meat. The majority of the selection is made up of mainstays like beef, pork, and chicken, though there are also seafood options like salmon.
The service offers everything from pre-breaded chicken strips to premium steaks. Most of the menu is basic cuts of meat like pork tenderloins or chicken thighs, but there are also flavored products like bacon and sausage.
Overall, I love the variety on ButcherBox’s menu. There’s also a good value to larger orders, especially when you consider the quality. You can get clear information on every cut of meat – just click on the little “i” icon in the lower-right corner.
Meal Options: Choose Between the Custom and Curated Plans
ButcherBox offers 2 meal plans: the Custom Plan and the Curated Plan. Each gives you access to a wide variety of products. The only difference is how much you want to be able to customize the items that go into your order.
The Curated Plan lets you choose the combination of meats you want to receive. You can opt for beef and chicken, beef and pork, or a combination of beef, pork, and chicken. There’s no beef-free option, and seafood isn’t available on this plan – though there are some add-ons.
The Custom Plan gives you more control over your menu, but for a higher cost. This menu is divided into 6 sections: Popular Cuts, Beef, Chicken, Pork, Seafood, and More. The More section has unique offerings like Black Bean Burgers and Ground Bison.
ButcherBox’s beef is sourced from Australia and certified as pasture-raised. Compared to conventional grocery meat, expect a richer flavor and better nutrients from this premium grass-fed and grass-finished beef.
The Pork section includes heritage breeds free from antibiotics and added hormones. All of ButcherBox’s premium pork products are raised using traditional, sustainable farming methods. This ensures a restaurant-quality dining experience.
ButcherBox also offers free-range organic chicken for those who prefer poultry. These humanely-raised chickens have access to outdoor space, resulting in better-tasting flesh from more active birds with less fat accumulation throughout their bodies.
The chickens are never given antibiotics or added hormones. They’re fed USDA-certified organic feed providing exceptional nutrition with each bite.
The Seafood section is filled with wild-caught fish and shellfish. You’ll find whole filets of premium fish like cod and salmon. ButcherBox also has some more processed options like Salmon Burgers and Smoked Salmon.
ButcherBox also offers add-ons. Add-ons are other cuts of meat or already cooked items, such as ground beef, bacon, pulled pork, chicken nuggets, and more. These are great to stock up on as they have a longer shelf life. Keep in mind that add-ons are recurring, so you’ll receive them in every box unless you change the order.
