Omaha Steaks Review 2024: Is the Meat Worth It?

Omaha Steaks is a meat production and delivery company offering a range of products to buyers across the USA. Customers can purchase their meats online or at 1 of its many stores all over the country. Along with their steaks, Omaha Steaks provides many other meat products, making it a one-stop shop for meat lovers.

Omaha Steaks also offers an array of side dishes, desserts, and seafood options besides meat products. You can complement the meats with sides and desserts. You can even purchase wine to pair with your meal through this service. Additionally, you can send or receive a gift with the Omaha Steaks brand and share your love for meat with your friends and relatives.

The company may offer special deals to new customers. It also grants discounts for holidays and other special occasions. There are often sales and promotions on the website too. So read our Omaha Steaks Review to learn more about the meat delivery service and get all the answers you need about meat quality, delivery options, and more.

What’s on the Omaha Steaks Menu

Omaha Steaks sources meat from the Midwest and sells its products nationwide. But the company reveals a little more than that regarding its meat origins. The company offers a wide range of meat products falling into several categories. Besides meat items, you can purchase various other foods and wines from Omaha Steaks.

Meal Options

Omaha Steaks caters to any eaters having some type of meat on their menus. Check the following table for a quick breakdown.

There are many Omaha Steaks meal options available on the website, and they fall into the following categories:

You can find various pork chops in the Chicken and Pork section, for example. Duroc Pork Rib, Smoked, Boneless, and Polynesian Pork Chops are a few among them. Salamis, Pot Roasts, and Loin Roasts are a few other available pork products.

The service also has a variety of fish and shellfish on offer. Among other options, you’ll find salmon, cod, tuna, crab, and scallops. And you can shortlist your options by selecting your favorite fish or shellfish.

You can mix and match meats from different categories during purchase. Select the desired products, and they’ll be added to the shopping cart which you’ll find in the upper right corner of the page. If you're looking for meals for an upcoming holiday, select the corresponding holiday option (Easter, for example) to see recommendations for the occasion.

Customization

You can buy most Omaha Steaks products as they are. Also, you can customize the selected products featuring the Build Custom Package button. In that case, you can personalize your meats by choosing from various selections.

For example, opt for Duroc Boneless Country Ham or New Zealand Boneless Leg of Lamb, among other alternatives, if you select the Create Your Own Easter Dinner option. Once you make the 1st choice, scroll down the side window to personalize other ingredients.

You typically have several options with most individual meat and seafood products. If you’re after Salmon meals, you can choose between 12 items. But, if you look for Pork, for example, you’ll find 46 different products, including steaks, chops, and ham. The Chicken assortment has 38 products, some of which are skewers, breasts, and leg quarters. On the other hand, the Caviar section has only 1 item – American Sturgeon Caviar.

Note that you can’t customize dishes to avoid allergens. If you check out Meals, Sides & Desserts, for instance, you can see common allergens, such as soy, listed in the meal’s Nutrition section.

Unboxing

Omaha Steaks uses heavy-duty packaging made of styrofoam to ship orders. You'll find dry ice maintaining a low temperature and keeping your products frozen inside the box. A list of the meats and other products you've purchased will also be in the box so you won’t be left guessing what’s what.

Items you purchased from Omaha Steaks are individually boxed in a cardboard package. To open the cardboard boxes, simply press the tab, and the lid will come off easily. Inside, you'll find your products packed in plastic bags. Styrodur and plastic bags keep your products frozen and prevent optional spills, but a big downside of these materials are that they aren’t eco-friendly.

Store your Omaha Steaks recipes in the freezer before thawing them for preparation. The service advises keeping your freezer at the lowest temperature possible and storing food in its original package, if applicable. Meat can last up to 3 months in the freezer, but you must thaw it in the fridge before preparing it. Depending on the product, thawing could take anywhere from 4 to 24 hours.

Call Omaha Steaks’ toll-free recycle hotline for info at 1-800-228-9872 about recycling. Agents will give you information about the nearest recycling facilities to you. 

Cooking With Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks meats are easy and quick to cook, with many items taking as little as 10 minutes to serve. Note, though, that cooking times vary depending on the meat type and its thickness. In light of that, some dishes make require up to 60 minutes preparation.

Preheat the grill to high temperature when gas grilling Omaha Steaks meats. Reduce the heat to medium before placing the meat on the grill. If using a charcoal grill, sear the meat over red hot coals to develop a nice crust. Afterward, move it to a cooler part of the grill to finish cooking over indirect heat.

To sear roast meat, start by preheating your oven to 300F. Then, heat a small amount of oil in a large ovenproof pan over high heat. When the pan is hot, add the meat and sear it for 2-3 minutes until it brows well. Flip the meat over and then place the pan in the preheated oven to finish cooking.

Shortlist of My Favorite Meals

I like PureGround Filet Mignon Burgers by Omaha Steaks. These burgers feature ground beef and are gluten-free, making them a great choice for keto and paleo dieters. Each burger has approximately 500 calories and weighs 6 ounces. PureGround Filet Mignon Burgers are available in packages of 4, 8, 12, 16, and 24 burgers.

I also highly recommend trying the Chicken Cordon Bleu. It features tender chicken breasts stuffed with Swiss cheese and hickory-smoked ham. Panko breadcrumbs bread these ingredients. Each serving contains 470 calories. Available packages include 2, 4, 6, and 8 items.

Prices

Everyone is eligible for the Omaha Steaks free membership program. Once you join, you'll start at the basic Member level. To advance to the Premium plan, you'll need to spend at least $300 in purchases within a 12-month period.

Prices of individual meals vary by a large margin. Private Reserve Filet Mignons, for example, cost at least $162. Live Maine Lobsters & Meal Kit is considerably cheaper and its price tag is $116. For Air-Chilled Boneless Chicken Breasts, you’ll have to pay $39.99.

Note that the shipping fee ranges from $44.99 to $129.99, depending on your location.

Shipping & Delivery

You can purchase Omaha Steaks products from anywhere in the US. You can order the meat delivery service's food even if you live in Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, or the US Virgin Islands. At this time, Omaha Steaks doesn’t deliver internationally. The company doesn’t specify what shipping times are. It only discloses that express shipping arrives in 2 or 3 days.

Omaha Steaks doesn’t deliver to P.O. Boxes or A.P.O. or F.P.O. addresses. However, you can use rural routes with complete addresses and telephone numbers to purchase the company's meals.

It's worth noting that Omaha Steaks provides free shipping on select products. It’s easy to find these items by looking for the Ships Free label at the top of the product while browsing the menu. Keep in mind that shipping fees may apply to other items you purchase.

How Omaha Steaks Works

Note that you can shop without creating an account on the website. Simply browse the selection of products by scrolling down the page, selecting items, and proceeding to checkout as a guest. Use the search box at the top of the page to look for specific products. You can fine-tune your search by selecting available tabs, such as Shipped Free and Value Assortments.

How To Sign Up

You don't have to open an account to buy via Omaha Steaks. But membership brings you various benefits, including faster points earning and occasional gifts.

Sign up on the Omaha Steaks website via a desktop computer, laptop, or mobile. Consider downloading the mobile app available on Google Play and the App Store for extra convenience. To register an account, do the following:

1. Select the Sign In button; if you're using a smartphone, only the icon without the text may appear.

2. Hit the Create Account button; once you do, the side window will appear.

3. Enter your name and email address and choose and confirm your password.

4. Select Create Account and that’s it.

Managing Your Account

You'll access the Membership Account page when you sign up. There, you can access various account management features. For example, you can review your past orders, update your address book, and more. I found the Membership Account page user-friendly and intuitive, and I was able to quickly and easily find the information I need.

I appreciate the feature allowing me to save my favorite products for future reference. The feature let me to state how I cook which in turn helped me personalize my shopping experience which is also great. Reviewing past and current orders and updating contacts and addresses is another great feature.

But Steaklovers Rewards is the most rewarding membership feature for me. The membership program has 3 plans: Member, Premium, and Gold. Both the Member and Premium plans are free to join, while the Gold plan requires an annual membership fee.

The Gold plan offers the most rewards, including earning more points per dollar spent. It also grants free shipments and gifts for purchases over $79.99. So, this plan can offer you significant savings and rewards if you're a frequent Omaha Steaks shopper.

Customer Service

I found Omaha Steaks' customer service difficult to find and quite inefficient. It took me some time and effort to locate Omaha Steaks' customer service and FAQ section as neither is prominently displayed on the website. I found Help Center at the bottom of the home page. Many other meal delivery services have customer support or FAQ sections clearly marked on their websites, even in the header.

I tried to find out the delivery time for Omaha Steaks shipments to Hawaii. Upon selecting Help Center, the system presented me with the frequently asked questions first. Since I couldn't find the answer, I had to click on the No, I need more info option in the Was this information helpful? box at the end of the FAQ section. The Contact Us button appeared only then.

I got a reply to my email quite quickly after I gave my personal information and asked my question. But the reply didn't answer my question and instead gave information on shipping fees to Hawaii. So, I think the service sent me a standard reply and that Omaha Steaks doesn't have dedicated customer service agents to answer specific questions.

I presumed that I would have to make a call to obtain the information since I couldn't locate a live chat option. Nevertheless, I was dissatisfied with the response from Omaha Steaks as it appeared as if they didn’t appreciate the effort I made in submitting my question.

The best way to cancel your membership is to call customer support since Omaha Steaks doesn’t have related information on its website. 

How Omaha Steaks Compares to Other Meal Delivery Services

• Omaha Steaks vs. Green Chef: Green Chef delivers fresh meals while Omaha Steaks ships frozen products. Plus, Green Chef, a certified-organic company, has various meal plans, including a Protein Packed option that’ll keep you full. Plus, Green Chef’s meal kits can feed you and your family without breaking the bank. Another crucial difference is that Green Chef uses eco-friendly packaging.

• Omaha Steaks vs. Blue Apron: Omaha Steaks doesn't offer personalization options for specific diets, such as vegetarian or low-calorie, unlike Blue Apron. You can also swap ingredients in various Blue Apron dishes to meet individual dietary needs. Blue Apron has excellent customer service, whereas Omaha Steaks' customer service is hard to find and not very efficient, in my experience. 

• Omaha Steaks vs. Crowd Cow: Both meat delivery services have a wide range of products. But, unlike Omaha Steaks, Crowd Cow sources meat from local and foreign suppliers. Thus, you can try products you usually don’t have an opportunity to taste with the latter. Plus, Crowd Cow’s packaging is eco-friendly, and the service provides you with several options to redeem reward points.

The Bottom Line: Is Omaha Steaks Worth It?

Omaha Steaks can be a good option for meat lovers seeking various meat products. The company provides free shipping for many of its items. Plus, the meat delivery service ships nationwide, including Alaska, Hawaii, and other non-mainland destinations.

However, Omaha Steaks isn't clear about how it sources meat. You can also find it challenging to locate Omaha Steaks' customer service, which can be impersonal. Moreover, the meal delivery service doesn't offer personalized meal plans for specific diets. If you're after these features, Green Chef may be a better option. Moreover, the packaging isn't eco-friendly, which may be a drawback for environmentally-conscious consumers.

Lastly, Omaha Steaks ships frozen meals. If you prefer fresh food, check out the top fresh meal delivery services.

FAQ

Is it worth buying from Omaha Steaks?

If you're a meat lover, Omaha Steaks should be worth a try. The company offers a wide range of meat products it delivers nationwide. But if knowing the origin of your meat is important to you, it may be best to consider other options.

Is Omaha Steaks good quality?

The quality of Omaha Steaks' meat products is inconclusive. The company has been in business for over 100 years, which should speak loudly about the quality of its meats. However, its meat grading and sourcing aren’t transparent. And this lack of transparency raises some concerns among consumers about the quality of their meat.

Are Omaha Steaks overpriced?

Omaha Steaks tends to be more expensive than many other online meat retailers. Check Porter Road or Crowd Cow, among other services, if you're on a budget.