Best Dog Food Delivery Brooklyn 2024: Ranked

Brooklyn dog owners have various pet shops in their neighborhood where they can buy meals and other essentials. But after reviewing many dog food delivery services, I concluded that ordering from these providers is a better option overall.

That said, not all pet food subscription services are created equal. The ones I recommend use human-grade ingredients and avoid questionable elements like mystery meats and fillers. The best services provide meal personalization tools and have their recipes formulated by veterinary experts. And they often offer treats, supplements, and other extras, too. 

I think that The Farmer's Dog is the best dog food delivery service overall, but each of the providers on my list stands out in some way. So, check out my Best Dog Food Delivery Brooklyn guide to see which one will suit your dog best.

The Best Dog Food Delivery for Brooklyn Reviewed

1. The Farmer’s Dog – Best Dog Food Delivery in Brooklyn

The Farmer's Dog specializes in grain-free dog food that’s always fresh. The company focuses on personalized, high-quality meals with 4 recipes developed under veterinary guidance with an emphasis on nutrition. You can tailor your dog's meals depending on their dietary needs and taste preferences via a questionnaire when you sign up.

What’s on Offer?

You can select from 4 recipes whose main ingredients are chicken, turkey, beef, and pork. These dishes include nutritious foods like carrots, broccoli, and Brussels sprouts, along with fiber-packed ingredients like chickpeas, lentils, and sweet potatoes. Every meal is rounded off with fish oil for complete nutritional balance.

The Farmer's Dog ensures its food has no superfluous or potentially harmful ingredients. This means your dog won't eat nutritionally void fillers, preservatives, brown pellets, or other additives. The meals contain only human-grade meats and vegetables. Moreover, its meals support dogs of all life stages and breeds.

You can serve food as it is. In other words, you don't have to cook or heat it. If your dog prefers food warm, just add a little warm water. You can learn many other useful details from our in-depth review.

What Makes It Special?

You can customize your pup's mealtime with The Farmer's Dog's meal personalization quiz, which I find pretty thorough. By answering questions about your dog's size, health, activity level, and food preferences, you'll get a tailored meal recommendation. This results in pre-portioned meals that meet your dog's caloric and nutritional needs.

The service stands out with its team of Ph.D. Board Certified Animal Nutritionists, a unique feature not commonly found nationwide. These experts help ensure that all recipes exceed the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) standards. 

Another convenience this provider offers is flexible delivery. You can expedite or delay delivery, depending on your needs.

Is It Good Value?

The Farmer's Dog's protein-rich meals provide great value for money. Moreover, many customers reported enhanced well-being in their pets after switching to the provider’s food. Some improvements they mentioned include better digestion, healthier skin and coat, and increased energy.

The price per meal depends on factors such as your pet's size, activity level, and health status. But, the most economical option begins at $2/day.

2. Ollie – Best Dry Recipes for Dogs

Ollie has fresh and baked meals on offer that meet high nutritional standards. It also has 3 meal plans, 1 of which lets you mix its fresh and dry meals if your dog likes crunchiness as much as you value nutrition. Besides, you can customize your dog's meal plan.

What’s on Offer?

Ollie provides 5 fresh and 2 dry recipes, each carefully processed to maintain their nutritional integrity. They feature a variety of proteins and include fruits and vegetables such as apples, butternut squash, carrots, and sweet potatoes. Every meal is free of corn, wheat, and other fillers.

The primary ingredients in Ollie's fresh recipes are pork, chicken, turkey, lamb, and beef. The beef and chicken recipes are baked varieties. Oats, cranberries, chickpeas, peas, spinach, and rice are some accompanying ingredients, depending on the selected meal.

Ollie also has treats and supplements on offer. The treats include Chicken and Apple Jerky Strips and Crunchy Treats With Sweet Potato, and there are 5 supplements including Probiotic Chews and Calming Chews.

What Makes It Special?

Complete Ollie's quiz to customize meals specifically for your dog. It covers various aspects, including your pup's breed, weight, age, and activity level. I find Ollie's quiz useful, but The Farmer's Dog’s survey covers more key points. So, consider it if you're feeding your dog fresh food.

Ollie offers 3 meal plans. The Fresh plan is the most beneficial, but you can choose the Half-Fresh plan if you want to blend Ollie's fresh recipes with meals from other brands. The Mixed plan merges Ollie's fresh and baked recipes, which is best for pet parents looking for quality and affordability. 

Ollie also provides a health screening for your dog. Once you subscribe, download the Ollie app and upload pictures of your dog. Through this service, you'll get insight into your canine’s digestion, dental health, and weight.

Is It Good Value?

Ollie is one of the top dog meal delivery services available nationwide. It sources high-quality ingredients both domestically and internationally. Also, Ollie creates meals that cater to picky eaters. Check out our complete review to learn more about the company.

The cost of Ollie's meals varies depending on many factors, including your dog's age, weight, and overall health. But the price per meal starts at $4-$8 per day.

3. We Feed Raw – Best Raw Meals for Brooklyn Pets

We Feed Raw produces unprocessed raw pet food. The company works closely with field experts to ensure its meals are complete, balanced, and safe to eat. Its food consists of animal proteins, with a few extra health-beneficial ingredients. You can find single- and multi-protein recipes on the menu. 

What’s on Offer?

We Feed Raw offers 6 raw meals with primary ingredients including chicken, turkey, beef, duck, lamb, and venison. These dishes are grain-free and fortified with essential vitamins and minerals. What's more, they are free from sugar, carbohydrates, fillers, preservatives, and other questionable ingredients.

The meals from this service are made up of meat, organs, and ground bones, and some of them contain proteins from various animals. For example, the Lamb and Duck Patty Recipes also incorporate beef and turkey, respectively. But the Chicken recipe contains only chicken meat. Read our review to learn more. 

You can order meals in 3 different box sizes depending on your dog’s size: Small, Classic, or Big for larger breeds. Note that purchases should meet the 30 lb increments, a measure taken to reduce the carbon footprint.

What Makes It Special?

We Feed Raw's foods contain 80% muscle meat, 10% organ meat, and 10% finely ground bone. The company highlights that ground meat you can find in a store is usually missing organ meat and bones, making it less balanced.

Tailor your dog's meal plan by completing a short questionnaire. This survey gathers details about your dog's age, breed, pickiness, and other relevant information. But the quiz doesn't delve into health issues like The Farmer's Dog quiz does. 

Is It Good Value?

We Feed Raw's food meets high safety and nutritional standards. It's beneficial for your pet's digestion, weight, skin, coat, and other health aspects. You can serve these meals as they are, optionally searing them slightly if your hound prefers it. 

The cost of We Feed Raw's food varies based on the chosen recipe and the size of the box. Prices begin at $6.59/lb, and pet parents from Brooklyn enjoy free shipping.

4. Nom Nom – Best Gently Cooked Dog Meals

Nom Nom specializes in gently cooked pet food, created by expert nutritionists. Its food offers various health benefits, and there are supplements, too. 

What’s on Offer?

Nom Nom offers 4 dog recipes – Beef Mash, Pork Potluck, Chicken Cuisine, and Turkey Fare. Each recipe includes a mix of vegetables such as peas, kale, and spinach, and some add eggs and mushrooms. Learn more about the service's ingredients from our expert review.

The variety pack is a good option if you’re unsure about your dog's recipe preferences. It contains 200 g of each meal, delivered frozen and requiring thawing before serving. 

The service also has a few supplements in its lineup. For dogs, it offers Full Spectrum and GI Targeted Probiotics. 

What Makes It Special?

A team of pros crafts Nom Nom's meals, including 2 Board Certified Veterinary Nutritionists. There are only about 100 such certified professionals in the US. The Farmer’s Dog is the only other dog food delivery service I reviewed that has board-certified vet nutritionists.

Nom Nom also offers a meal personalization quiz tailored for dogs. It considers your pet's age, body condition, and any specific allergies or sensitivities. 

Is It Good Value?

Nom Nom's meals are among the best on the market — and shipping for Brooklyn pet parents is free, saving you time and money. 

The price of Nom Nom's meals depends on many factors, but its most budget-friendly option costs $5/day.

5. Spot & Tango – Best UnKibble Recipes for Brooklyn Dogs

Spot and Tango caters to pet parents who feed their dogs both fresh and dry meals. The dry meals are prepared using a unique Fresh Dry™ process. Also, you can customize your dog's meal plan through a detailed on-site quiz. The company offers recipes with and without grains.

What’s on Offer?

Spot and Tango offers 4 dry and 3 fresh meals. These are suitable for dogs at any life stage, from puppies to seniors. In most recipes, a specific protein is the primary ingredient, followed by vegetables or grains as the next main ingredient, depending on your choice.

Dry meals on offer are Cod + Salmon, Beef + Barley, Chicken + Brown Rice, and Turkey + Sweet Potato. These are made with fresh ingredients, meeting the AAFCO nutritional standards. Read our full review to learn more about the company’s UnKibble brand. 

Spot and Tango's fresh meals are Turkey + Red Quinoa, Beef + Millet, and Lamb + Brown Rice. If you're after a larger assortment of fresh, grain-free recipes, check out The Farmer's Dog. 

What Makes It Special?

The UnKibble line of dry meals is Spot and Tango’s distinctive brand. These recipes contain fresh, wholesome ingredients that undergo a unique Fresh Dry™ process instead of extrusion. This preserves the nutritional value and quality of the ingredients.

You can personalize your dog's meal plan by completing a short questionnaire. This survey considers various factors, including your pet's age, gender, body condition, and activity level. It also includes a list of around 20 health issues, making it 1 of the best quizzes, in my opinion.

Is It Good Value?

Spot and Tango is a great choice if you're after fresh or high-quality dry meals for your dog. But it doesn't have treats and supplements — Ollie on the other hand has these extras, along with highly nutritious fresh and dry meals. 

Several factors affect the cost per meal, including your dog's size, age, and health. Pricing begins at $7 per week, and residents of Brooklyn enjoy free shipping.

6. The Pets Table – Vet-Crafted Fresh and Dry Dog Meals

The Pets Table is a pet meal line founded by HelloFresh, a renowned meal kit delivery service. It sources top-quality ingredients from around the world and prepares them in the USA. Expert pet nutritionists design the meals, and the service has specialized dogs who test the meals and give their seal of approval.

What’s on Offer?

The Pets Table offers 5 meals, 3 of which are fresh and 2 of which are dry. Fresh meals feature chicken, beef, and turkey as primary ingredients. Dry meals contain chicken and beef. Each recipe is paired with a unique secondary ingredient that enhances the main protein.

The provider’s dry recipes include Chicken & Sweet Potato and Beef & Berries. The Chicken & Sweet Potato recipe is beneficial for belly health and immunity, while the Beef & Berries recipe supports vision and coat health. Note that the Chicken & Sweet Potato recipe contains grains.

The fresh meal choices are Chicken Casserole with Green Beans, Beef Stew with Carrots, and Turkey Casserole with Broccoli. All these meals are made with human-grade ingredients. The chicken recipe is the only grain-free option. Read our review to learn more about the company's recipes. 

What Makes It Special?

Before ordering, you'll need to take a meal customization quiz. The system will suggest a proper calorie intake for your dog upon completion. After that, you can choose 1 of 4 meal plans: Air-Dried (the most budget-friendly), Fresh (the tastiest), Mixed (the most popular), and Half of Fresh. Opt for Half of Fresh if you're looking to mix meals from this service with those from another provider.

The company boasts a team of dog food tasters: a Shihchon, a Cavapoo, and a Bernedoodle. Meals only make it to the market after receiving approval from these canine experts.

Is It Good Value?

The Pets Table is a fine choice if you’re after dry or fresh meals. The company has made it to our list of the best dog food delivery services with no recalls. Its tasty meals contain wholesome ingredients and are free from additives, preservatives, and other by-products.

However, The Pets Table doesn’t offer health-beneficial treats or supplements — if you need these, I'd recommend Ollie. 

The cost per serving depends on the meal you choose and various factors like your dog's size and appetite. Still, the most budget-friendly meal options start at $1.59 per meal. Keep in mind that air-dried food is generally more affordable than fresh options.

7. PawFoods – Fresh Food With Organic Ingredients

PawFoods offers high-quality meals brimming with beneficial foods. In terms of meals, it has only a handful of fresh recipes. But it makes up for the limited menu with the excellent quality of the ingredients, and you get free extras with every meal you buy. 

What’s on Offer?

PawFoods provides 3 fresh recipes – Steak Sensation, Chicken Feast, and Under the Sea. Each suits different health requirements, with Under the Sea being the only grain-free option. Also, Under the Sea boasts the highest fiber content among the service's offerings, making it 1 of the top high-fiber dog food brands.

The Steak Sensation includes beef sirloin steak, kidney, and liver. It also contains fruits and veggies, including carrots, sweet potatoes, and strawberries, many of which are organic. Steak Sensation supports hips and joints, while Chicken Feast enhances immunity and Under the Sea is effective in combating allergies.

PawFoods offers Fruity Paws, Minty Paws, and Salmon Paws treats. These organic and gluten-free treats support your canine's teeth, joints, and skin health. Take a look at our insightful review to learn more. 

What Makes It Special?

PawFoods sources only high-quality ingredients, and most of them are organic. For instance, Steak Sensation includes organic eggs, along with various fruits and vegetables. 

The company adds dental treats with every meal, and each of its recipes comes with vitamin boosters. These additions make this provider stand out among the dog food delivery services shipping their products to Brooklyn. 

Is It Good Value?

PawFoods offers great value, with meals and treats teeming with the highest quality ingredients. As a result, the pricing is relatively high. But if prices are within your budget, PawFoods is a top choice for your dog's nutrition.

The lack of a meal customization quiz is the main reason I didn't place this service higher on the list. To tailor meals for your dog according to its age, intolerances, and health, I recommend The Farmer's Dog. 

The price of your dog's diet with PawFoods will vary based on their size, appetite, and other considerations. Still, the most budget-friendly product starts at $2.86 per meal.

8. Maev – Raw Meals Targeting Health Issues

Maev focuses on quality, providing only a select range of products made with high-quality ingredients. If you choose this provider, you'll feed your pup human-grade fruits, vegetables, and superfoods. You can also buy bundles tailored to different dog sizes and conditions. Maev has earned its place as one of the best raw dog food delivery services. 

What’s on Offer?

Maev has 2 raw meals on offer, and beef and chicken are their primary ingredients. Both meals also have zucchini, kale, blueberries, and blanched potatoes. Besides fruits and vegetables, they also contain probiotics.

This service provides 4 treats, each with a clear purpose indicated by its name: Hip & Joint, Skin & Coat, Anxiety & Calming, and Weight & Digestion. The treats contain beneficial ingredients like omega-3, glucosamine, and more.

Maev has a bone broth topper on offer that contains amino acids and collagen, offering various health benefits for your dog. This supplement improves skin and coat, belly, cartilage, and joint health. Check our review to learn more about Maev’s products. 

What Makes It Special?

Maev's tailored bundles are designed for your dog's health condition, age, and size. Among the 8 available options are The Gassy Dog, The Small Dog, and The Puppy Bundles. Each package includes different meals and extras tailored to specific needs.  

The Customize tool helps you tailor your dog's meal plan. Enter details like your dog's age, weight, body condition, and activity level, and it will provide a recommended daily calorie intake converted into cups. Click on the Size tab when browsing meals to find this helpful feature.

Maev has a comparison tool to compare its foods against those from other providers. It allows comparisons based on Brands, Health Focus, and Ingredients.

Is It Good Value?

Maev's meals improve your pet's well-being by addressing various health issues. Its packages cater to different dog sizes, ages, and conditions. Due to their high nutritional value and many health benefits, Maev's products are priced on the higher side.

The limited meal selection is another weak spot of this service. For these reasons, you may want to consider We Feed Raw as an alternative, as it has a larger menu and is more affordable. 

The cost of your pet's diet with Maev depends on many factors, but the company's cheapest item will set you back $143 per bag.

9. Raised Right – Human-Grade Canine Food

Raised Right produces first-class fresh meals for dogs. It has fresh recipes for puppies and adult dogs, but also pâtés. Veterinarians design meals that undergo rigorous safety checks before being shipped. And you can estimate the cost of your dog's mealtime via an on-site calculator. For these reasons, this provider ranks among the best fresh dog food delivery services. 

What’s on Offer?

Raised Right provides Beef, Chicken, and Turkey Growth Recipes for young dogs. Adult dogs have 8 options, 4 of which are pâtés. The fresh choices for adult dogs are Original Turkey, Beef, Pork, and Chicken. The pâtés include these same proteins, with pumpkin added to the mix.

The service's meals contain human-grade ingredients. What's more, the company consults with a vet who creates recipes specifically for each dog's life stage. 

You can buy various treats for your pets. The selection includes Meat Bites, available in turkey, pork, lamb, and beef liver flavor, and Shake A Flakes toppers in beef, turkey, and lamb varieties. Read our complete review for further info.

What Makes It Special?

Raised Right offers a food calculator to learn how much your dog's food will cost. This feature considers a few basic factors, such as your pet's weight, activity level, and your weight management objectives. 

But note that this is not a meal customization quiz. For a meal plan tailored to your dog's needs, you might want to check out Spot and Tango, which has fresh and dry meals. 

You can trace every Raised Right ingredient back to its source. Additionally, the company is dedicated to environmental sustainability. It works with carbonfund.org to counterbalance carbon emissions and rePurpose Global to remove plastic waste from the environment.

Is It Good Value?

Raised Right produces high-quality dog food that meets the AAFCO standards, making it a reliable choice for Brooklyn pet owners. If you're uncertain whether their recipes will suit your dog, buy a Sample Box to test the waters before committing.

Your dog’s size, activity level, and weight management goals are some factors that will influence cost, but Raised Right’s most affordable product costs $9.99/bag. Note that Brooklyn pet parents enjoy free shipping unless they buy a Sample Box. In this case, the shipping fee is $9.99.

10. Jinx – Top Wet Pup Food

Jinx is 1 of the leading providers of wet meals for dogs. It has grain-free and cereal-inclusive recipes. Besides wet meals, you can buy dry dishes for your dog from this service. What's more, it has treats, chews, and toppers on offer, making it a 1-stop shop for your pet's needs. 

What’s on Offer?

Jinx has 6 wet recipes, including 3 pâtés. The main ingredients in the pâtés are beef, chicken, and salmon, each paired with sweet potato as a secondary ingredient. The Homemade variants on offer are Chicken, Beef & Chicken, and Chicken & Tuna.

Jinx also has 8 dry meal options. These feature a variety of proteins and vegetables, with some combinations including salmon, beef, sweet potato, and carrots. For more detailed information about Jinx's meals, I recommend checking out our review.

You can also buy treats, chews, meal toppers, and bundles from this company. Some treats on offer are broth biscuits and tenders, while available toppers are Freeze-Dried Salmon and Chicken & Pumpkin Toppers. You can also buy bundles such as Picky Dog Essentials and Sensitive Stomach Essentials Starter Packs. 

What Makes It Special?

Pet nutritionists, veterinarians, formulators, and other experts are involved in the creation of Jinx's recipes. As a result, these meals are free from fillers like corn, additives, and other undesirable ingredients. This puts Jinx among the best wet dog food delivery services nationwide.

The provider donates a part of each purchase to help dogs in need. Specifically, it contributes 1% of every purchase to nonprofit organizations like Animal Haven and Wags and Walks. Thanks to pet parents, over 300,000 meals have been provided to pups in need so far.

Is It Good Value?

Yes, if your dog enjoys wet or dry meals — the company offers a broader assortment of each than many of its competitors. Also, the service is an excellent choice for animal lovers who want to make a meaningful impact, as each purchase contributes food to dogs without owners.

But I find the lack of a meal customization quiz to be a drawback. If you need a personalized diet for your puppy or adult dog, I think that Spot and Tango would be a better choice. 

The cost of each meal from Jinx varies based on the product type and the package selected. But, the most budget-friendly option starts at $30/bag. Brooklyn pet owners should aim for a purchase of at least $50 to take advantage of free delivery.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Dog Food in Brooklyn

You should consider several key factors when selecting your ideal meal delivery service that ships to Brooklyn. The most important considerations are:

• Identify the type of food your dog likes best. While some dogs enjoy fresh meals, others prefer dry or raw options. Also, consider whether your dog needs a grain-inclusive or grain-free diet. If you combine dry and fresh meals for your pup, consider using Ollie.

• Think about personalizing your dog's food. Customization can make quite a difference because each dog has unique nutritional needs. Top vendors have quizzes that ask about various aspects, such as breed, age, and palate. I find The Farmer's Dog's quiz particularly comprehensive because, unlike most of its competitors, it touches on health issues.

• Consider whether your dog needs extra support. Several services in my list provide treats and supplements that can delight your pup or address some common canine health issues. Nom Nom has supplements, plus a microbiome testing kit, which can be a valuable tool in assessing your dog's health.

• Consider the value for money. While staying within your budget is crucial, it's equally important to determine the value of the product you're ordering. When it comes to raw pet food, We Feed Raw stands out as a great value because its dishes contain virtually 100% animal-derived ingredients. 

FAQ

Which is the best online dog food?

It depends on your pup's dietary needs, but I believe The Farmer's Dog earns at least a place in the top 3 online dog foods. This is due to its straightforward labeling, commitment to sourcing only high-quality ingredients, and its excellent meal personalization quiz.  

Is it cheaper to buy dog food online or in the store?

I've seen online retailers having lower prices than brick-and-mortar stores and vice versa. But ordering online offers various benefits. It saves you time and you can personalize your pup's mealtime. In this regard, Ollie stands out among the pet food delivery services.  

Are dog food subscriptions worth it?

Yes, dog food subscriptions that feature food with human-grade ingredients and meet AAFCO standards are worth it. They deliver tailored, high-quality meals directly to your doorstep. That way, they ensure your dog's dietary needs are consistently met without the hassle of frequent store visits.

Best Dog Food Delivery in Brooklyn in 2024 — Final Score