6 Best Dog Subscription Boxes 2024: Expert Ranked

It can be lots of fun to spoil your pup. Seeing their excited, wagging tails when a new toy or treat appears is priceless. But finding new and good-quality toys and treats can take time. This is where dog subscription boxes come in.

We've spent a lot of time looking at the different dog subscription boxes out there. We considered how durable the toys are, how good the treats are, how much they cost, and what makes them unique.

Out of all the dog subscription boxes, BarkBox stands out. It's our favorite because of the high-quality and the variety of items. Plus, the monthly themes are really fun. Keep reading to find out all about BarkBox, plus some other great options for your dog.

The Best Dog Subscription Boxes Reviewed

1. BarkBox – Best Overall Dog Subscription Box

BarkBox is a favorite among pet parents and my number 1 choice for dog subscription boxes. After researching all the details, it’s easy to see why it's such a popular choice.

What’s on Offer?

Every BarkBox includes 2 toys, 2 treats, and surprise activities and games. The toys tend to be fluffy, squeaky, and cuddly, so they won’t stand up to aggressive chewing. All the treats are wheat, corn, and soy-free, catering to the health needs and dietary restrictions of many dogs.

BarkBox offers a high degree of flexibility and adaptability. It provides 3 different box types designed for small, medium, or large breeds. These are all the same price and contain the same number of items. I like that you can change the type of box at any time, so your pup gets toys and treats that match their size.

This means as your pup grows, so does its BarkBox. It's a thoughtful feature that shows BarkBox's understanding of your dog’s journey. However, it's worth noting that the box is most suitable for dogs aged 6 months and above.

What Makes It Special?

My favorite thing about BarkBox is the monthly themes. This definitely adds a layer of uniqueness and excitement to every delivery. Some previous themes have included movie night, aliens, Harry Potter, and even Stranger Things. Get ready to party every month, as you never know what you’re going to get.

Perhaps most reassuring is the company's satisfaction guarantee. If you're not satisfied with the box, you can get a refund. And with the option to cancel monthly subscriptions at any time, you maintain control over the service.

I’m happy to learn that the company donates to rescue and shelter partners. This means you can feel really good about supporting it. Read our full review to find out more about the Bark company.

Is It Good Value?

You can opt for a 1, 6, or 12-month subscription, which automatically renews for your convenience. Shipping is an additional $5 per delivery unless your order exceeds $35, in which case shipping is free. This is 1 way you can customize your subscription.

Plans start from $22/month if you opt for the 12-month subscription. Your first box will be shipped to your door in around 5 days.

2. Bark Super Chewer – Best Dog Subscription Box for Heavy Chewers

If your dog loves chewing, the Super Chewer box stands out. Created by the folks behind BarkBox, this subscription service is thoughtfully designed for those enthusiastic chewers who turn plush toys into confetti in mere seconds.

What’s on Offer?

The box contents are similar to its BarkBox counterpart. You get a surprise themed box every month. It includes 2 toys and 2 treats, catering to the relentless chewing habits of your energetic dog.

The toys are engaging, helping to keep your pup entertained for longer periods. And the treats are wheat, corn, and soy-free, much to the delight of health-conscious pet parents. If your dog has other allergies, you can easily contact customer services to let them know.

The company is committed to customer satisfaction. Its money-back guarantee and hassle-free cancelation policy for monthly subscriptions is impressive. Check out our review for more details.

What Makes It Special?

A key feature of Super Chewer that deserves a special mention is the chewed-toy replacement policy. If your dog manages to destroy any of the included toys, the company will replace them for free! A guarantee like this offers peace of mind and reflects Super Chewer's confidence in the product's durability.

Like BarkBox, Super Chewer offers flexible subscription options. Choose from 1, 6, or 12 months, each auto-renewing for seamless continuation. It also follows the same shipping policy, charging $5 per delivery unless your order exceeds $35.

Is It Good Value?

Super Chewer takes durability seriously. The toys included in the box are robust and sturdy. They’re engineered to endure the toughest of chewers. 

Prices start from $22/month when you take out a 12-month subscription. If you're the proud parent of an enthusiastic chewer, Super Chewer is a solution designed to withstand your dog's love for chewing and enhance their playtime.

3. PupBox – Best Dog Subscription Box for Puppies

PupBox is part of the Petco group and caters to the unique needs of your growing puppy. This dog subscription box is thoughtfully designed to evolve with your pup.

What’s on Offer?

What sets PupBox apart is its attention to detail in addressing each stage of puppy growth. Each box is curated to match your puppy's current stage, ensuring the items received are just what they need. A typical PupBox contains 5 to 7 treats, toys, and accessories.

However, what truly shines about PupBox is the addition of training guides. These comprehensive manuals become an invaluable resource for pet parents, offering tips and tricks on grooming, exercise, and games.

This is a great way to help navigate the difficult teething stage. It becomes less daunting with PupBox's special toys aimed at soothing delicate gums and deterring those playful bites. Check out our full review for more about the different life stages of PupBoxes.

What Makes It Special?

When you sign up, you need to select the best size for your puppy. These range from Itty Bitty for dogs up to 10 lbs, to Large & In Charge for larger breed pups over 50 lbs. You also need to enter your dog’s coat type, so you can get suitable grooming tools to fit your dog’s needs.

Beyond the monthly box, PupBox also offers an additional shopping feature. It's a handy option if your puppy has taken a particular liking to an item from a previous box, and you'd like to stock up. You can find accessories, health care items, and grooming accessories, as well as treats, chews, and toys.

You can even purchase themed boxes as one-time purchases. This includes an adorable birthday box that makes your pup's special day even more fun. There’s also the option to send PupBox as a gift. You don’t need to have a subscription to order additional shop items.

Is It Good Value?

It's important to note that PupBox isn’t the best choice for senior dogs. PupBox's focus is primarily on puppies and younger dogs. For senior pets, I'd recommend considering alternatives like BarkBox, which caters more broadly to all ages.

Subscription options for PupBox are flexible, and you can select a 1, 3, 6, or 12-month plan. The longer-term subscriptions offer a more affordable rate, making them a good choice for those ready to commit. Prices start at $29/box, and shipping is $3.99 unless you order additional treats every month, in which case shipping is free..

4. BoxDog – Best Customizable Dog Subscription Box

BoxDog is a great choice for pet parents seeking a customizable subscription box. This subscription service takes personalization to a whole new level, allowing you to curate a box that fits your dog perfectly.

What’s on Offer?

The selection offered by BoxDog is incredibly varied. You can choose from a range of treats, clothing, vegan skincare items, and toys, ensuring your box is as unique as your pet. The freedom to pick and choose not only creates a tailored experience but also lets you discover and experiment with new products.

While customization is great, it does mean your box won't come as a surprise, as you'll need to edit your order. If the element of surprise is important to you, services like BarkBox or Bark Super Chewer may be more fitting.

BoxDog doesn't stop at monthly boxes, as it also has a separate shop. Here, you can order extra items like bedding, jackets, and even a birthday cake to make your dog's (or cat’s) special day all the more memorable.

What Makes It Special?

BoxDog offers a monthly plan where you can select 5 or 6 items. The company keeps things fresh, introducing new products each month and offering the flexibility to skip months as needed.

If you prefer an even bigger treat, the quarterly seasonal box could be the way to go. We thought these boxes were more substantial when we reviewed the service. They contain 6 or 7 items and are delivered every 3 months.

Is It Good Value?

With BoxDog, quality takes center stage. Its treats are all handmade, with listed ingredients to help you keep track of any potential allergens. In fact, they’re so wholesome that you could, in theory, eat them yourself (just don’t let your dog catch you in the act!).

Subscription options are either monthly or seasonal, and prices start at $35/month if you prepay for 6 months. Shipping is free for customers in the US.

5. Pet Treater – Best Value Dog Subscription Box 

In the world of dog subscription boxes, Pet Treater offers a range of affordable options. This versatile service invites pet parents to customize boxes based on their dogs' unique needs and preferences. Whether your dog fancies treats, toys, or a mix of both, Pet Treater has a box to suit your dog.

What’s on Offer?

A standout feature of Pet Treater is the ability to order a “toys only” box. This option is particularly appealing for those whose pets are on specialized diets, allowing you to treat your dog to a fun toy without worrying about dietary restrictions.

If you’re the owner of a particularly pampered pet, Pet Treater offers a luxury deluxe box. This is a premium treat for those dogs that have been very, very good indeed.

In terms of quantity, Pet Treater delivers value for money. Regular boxes come packed with 3 or 4 items, while deluxe boxes are even more generous, containing 5 to 8 items. Our review has more details on the variety of exciting items you can expect to discover each month.

What Makes It Special?

Pet Treater also tailors boxes according to your dog's size. This means toys and treats are just the right fit. However, if you're the parent of a young pup, I recommend opting for PupBox, which specializes in catering to the unique needs of growing puppies.

There’s a one-time purchase option, so you can test out the service and see if your pup approves. This flexible approach is a testament to Pet Treater's commitment to customer satisfaction.

Is It Good Value?

Pet Treater offers subscription boxes for dogs of various sizes. It carefully curates boxes for each pet, dog or cat, and the company tries to maximize the value of the box as much as possible while maintaining a reasonable cost. 

There’s a range of subscription options from 1 to 12 months. Pet Treater accommodates varying commitments and budgets, with prices starting at $15/month. If you want to share the joy of a Pet Treater box with another pet parent, there's also the option to gift a box.

6. Chewy – Best for No-Subscription Dog Boxes

Chewy’s Goody Box is a no-strings-attached treat for your furry friend. The benefit is that you can order from a huge range of other dog and pet-related items from Chewy when you make your purchase.

What’s on Offer?

The box contains a variety of dog products, including treats, toys, food toppers, and other exclusive items. Thus, it ensures a broad spectrum of goodies that cater to all of your dog's interests. Check out our Chewy review to find out more about the products.

A fun and engaging element of the Goody Box is its themed approach. Each box carries a theme, ranging from Back to School to Adventure to Disney. These themes add a splash of excitement to the unboxing process, making it an enjoyable experience for both you and your pet.

It’s great that you can filter boxes based on special dietary needs. Whether your dog requires a limited ingredient diet, a rawhide-free diet, or prefers human-grade food, Chewy's selection has got you covered. However, inspecting the box contents is essential to ensure they're suitable for your pet's specific needs.

What Makes It Special?

Chewy's Goody Box is particularly good for special occasions. Whether you're celebrating your pet's birthday or welcoming a new pup into your family, a Goody Box can provide an excellent and thoughtful gift.

Goody Box is a one-time purchase, but it may offer an auto-ship option for certain boxes. At the time of writing, I could only see 1 box this applied to when I checked. If a regular subscription is what you're after, BarkBox might be a better fit for your needs with its monthly deliveries.

Is It Good Value?

The Goody Box is a treasure chest of dog-friendly delights, packing 5 or more items in every box. This value-packed approach saves you money compared to buying each item individually.

Puppy owners should note that the selection of puppy-specific boxes is limited. For a better selection of options for young dogs, PupBox would be a more suitable choice.

Pricing for Chewy's Goody Boxes starts at <$2 per meal, with delivery at $4.95. However, if you're looking to purchase more items at the same time and your total exceeds $49, delivery is free.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Dog Subscription Boxes

Here are some key considerations to keep in mind that can help guide your decision:

• Your dog’s size and breed: This is a crucial factor to consider while selecting a dog subscription box. Size-specific boxes, like those offered by BarkBox, ensure the toys and treats are appropriately sized for your dog's breed. This prevents potential choking hazards and ensures your dog can enjoy the products safely.

• Consider materials: If your dog is an aggressive chewer, a box designed for heavy chewers, like the Bark Super Chewer, would be more suitable. These boxes typically include durable toys made from tougher materials that can withstand powerful jaws. If your dog is less interested in chewing, choose a box with softer, plush toys.

• Customizable options: Take note of what gets your dog excited. This will help you find out whether they’re motivated by food or prefer playtime with toys. Some boxes are more treat-oriented, providing a wide variety of snacks, while others emphasize exciting new toys. Pet Treater has options for treat-only or toy-only boxes.

• Puppy-Oriented Box: If you're a pet parent to a young fur baby, selecting a puppy-oriented subscription box can make a significant difference. Puppies have different needs compared to adult dogs, so a box specifically designed for puppies, like the PupBox from Petco, can better cater to those unique requirements.

FAQ

What is a dog subscription box?

A dog subscription box is a recurring delivery of dog-related products. It typically includes a mix of toys, treats, grooming products, and other accessories. The contents of the box are usually curated based on your pet's size, breed, and dietary preferences, providing a personalized experience for your pet. BarkBox is a good example of a dog subscription service.

What is the best dog subscription box?

Are dog subscription boxes worth it?

Yes, dog subscription boxes are worth it if you enjoy treating your dog to new toys and treats regularly. They offer a convenient way to discover new products that your pet might enjoy. PupBox, for example, offers boxes tailored to puppies' developmental stages and also includes training guides, making it a valuable resource for new pet parents.

Can you get a dog subscription box for heavy chewers?

Absolutely, Bark Super Chewer is a dog subscription box designed for heavy chewers. Its boxes include toys made from more durable materials to withstand aggressive chewing. Bark Super Chewer is a box from the same creators as BarkBox, but it is specifically designed for dogs that need tougher toys.

Best Dog Subscription Box in 2024 — Final Score