Are Rastelli's products ethically and sustainably sourced?

Rastelli's is committed to only sourcing from farms that follow the strictest standards of animal welfare, environmental welfare, and sustainability practices. The company prioritizes partnering with local, family-owned operations whenever possible. Rastelli’s sourcing practices are what created and sustained its reputation as a meat and seafood delivery service that’s a cut above the rest.

What sets Rastelli's apart from other meat and seafood delivery services in 2025?

Rastelli's only sources meat and seafood from family-owned, sustainable farms and fisheries, which is why you’ll see farm sources from all over the world. The founders – brothers Ray and Tony – curated their product sourcing since the company opened almost 5 decades ago and have found the best farms to offer premium cuts of organic, grass-fed, and wild-caught meat and seafood free from hormones, steroids, and antibiotics.

How does Rastelli's ensure the freshness and quality of their meat and seafood?

Rastelli's works directly with farmers and fishermen to ensure its practices meet rigorous animal and environmental welfare standards. It also use innovative packaging techniques , such as vacuum-sealing and flash-freezing, to maintain freshness during transit. All products are shipped in insulated, eco-friendly packaging with dry ice to guarantee that your meat and seafood arrive at your doorstep in perfect condition.

How does Rastelli's delivery work and what are the shipping costs?

Rastelli's delivers to the contiguous US and shipping costs vary according to order total. You’ll receive an email with an order confirmation and UPS tracking information as soon as you confirm your order. Shipping varies from $0 to $25 depending on the order amount and delivery location. Shipping is free for all orders $200 and up.

Can I customize my Rastelli's order to suit my dietary needs?

Yes – Unless otherwise stated, Rastellis’ products arrive raw and unseasoned . You’ll still find some meats already rubbed and seasoned, but most arrive raw and without seasoning. This gives you total freedom for choosing whatever prep style you prefer. You can choose the type, cut, grade, and amount of protein.

We rank vendors based on rigorous testing and research, but also take into account your feedback and our commercial agreements with providers. This page contains affiliate links.Advertising DisclosureThis is a user-oriented comparison website, and we need to cover hosting and content costs, as well as make a profit. The costs are covered from referral fees from the vendors we feature. Affiliate link compensation does not affect reviews but might affect listicle pages. On these pages, vendors are ranked based on the reviewer’s examination of the service but also taking into account feedback from users and our commercial agreements with service providers. This website tries to cover important meal, coffee and pet food delivery services but we can’t cover all of the solutions that are out there. Information is believed to be accurate as of the date of each article.

back

Hmmm...

we couldn't find any matches for {value} double check your search for any typos

Rastelli’s Review 2025: Premium Meat & Seafood

Item: Rastellis
Author: Chelsea Legay

8.2

Our Rating

Meal Types:Protein packs

Diet Options:Carnivore, Pescatarian

Weekly Menu Options:100+ options

Shipping Fee0-$25

Take $15 off your first purchase over $50 code RASTELLIS15

www.rastellis.com

Chelsea Legay Writer

Fact checked by Emma Vince

Updated on May 6th, 2025

Overview

Rastelli’s is a leader in premium meats and seafood, offering high-quality, sustainably sourced products. You can choose from 6 categories of proteins: beef, poultry, seafood, pork, specialty meats, and Primals. There are also sides and desserts to complete your meal. Each product is carefully prepared, vacuum-packed, and flash-frozen to preserve flavor and nutritional value.

Rastelli’s prioritizes responsible sourcing, partnering with ethical farmers and fisheries to ensure products – from grass-fed beef to sustainably caught seafood – meet high-quality standards. Detailed product labeling helps you make informed decisions about every purchase.

I was impressed by the level of customization. You can choose the cut, grade, and quantity of each protein. You can also select rubs and butters that are ideal for pairing with your chosen meat. The user-friendly website also provides cooking tips and recipes, making preparing meat easy for both novice and experienced cooks.

Rastelli’s offers flexible delivery schedules, allowing you to order as little or as much as you want, with options for delivery every 1-6 weeks. Bundles are available for cost savings, and every item is priced individually for transparency. I found that shipping is only available to the continental US, and small orders incur a $25 shipping fee, while orders over $200 qualify for free shipping.

Overall, Rastelli’s excels in providing exceptional quality and service, making it an excellent choice for those seeking premium meats and seafood with a focus on sustainability and ethical practices.

pros

Transparent, ethical sourcingPremium cattle like Black Angus & WagyuPayment plans available

cons

High shipping fee on smaller ordersShipping charged on most ordersOnly email or phone customer support

Rastelli’s Menu: A Good Selection of Quality Meat & Seafood

Rastelli’s menu is packed with high-quality proteins and sides and is best for omnivores. You should consider it a premium butcher shop from which you can purchase meats and seafood to fill your fridge for the week, month, or for a special occasion.

Meal Options: Choose From 6 Protein Categories

You’ll find 6 categories of proteins: beef, seafood, poultry, pork, specialty meats, and Primals. Each category includes cuts of meat from different animals and fish, and each cut includes various grades, portion sizes, and amounts you can order at a time. This means you have tons of options to choose the perfect meats for your needs.

Some meats and fish are available seasonally due to harvesting restrictions but also to ensure they mature naturally and to the highest quality. So availability can be limited for certain specialty meats and fish. Otherwise, you’ll always see an excellent selection of beef, poultry, seafood, and pork year round. Rastelli’s always covers the protein basics and some.

You can also browse by “collections” such as roasts, sausages, and burgers to find partially prepped and seasoned meat and fish.

screenshot of Rastelli's main menu options

Rastelli’s is truly a boutique butcher service, and I’m thoroughly impressed with its quality. You’ll find nothing less than the best grades and cuts of meat and fish on its menu. What a resource for people who want the highest quality cuts of proteins from farms with expert animal welfare and environmental standards.

You won’t find prepared meals, but you’ll find meats, fish, sides, and desserts. All products are oven-ready unless you’d like to flex your chef skills and add your own marinade and seasoning.

You can order from 1 item to unlimited amounts of each product unless otherwise specified. You’ll even find several bundle options available. All you need to know is how many people you hope to feed and over what period of time.

screenshot of Rastelli's Grass-Fed Ribeye product information

Rastelli’s Partners Only With Sustainably-Run Farms

Rastelli’s only sources meat and fish from the best family farms from all over the world that use zero hormones, steroids, and antibiotics and raise animals in habitats as close to their natural ones as possible. All seafood is wild-caught or sustainably raised in free-flowing water fisheries to ensure animals and their natural habitats are treated with the highest welfare standards.

screenshot of Rastelli's protein categories with outdoor imagery

You’ll also find organic, pastured, antibiotic-free, and hormone-free poultry. Chicken and turkey are pasture-raised, fed an all-vegetarian diet, and live on farms that pass the Humane Farm Animal Care (HFAC) standards for humane welfare and environmental treatment.