9 Best Italian Wine Clubs 2024: Salute!

The abundance of Italian Wine Clubs can be overwhelming. Choosing a club that aligns with your convenience, desired price point, and level of wine expertise is crucial. It’s also worth noting that not all popular wine clubs regularly feature Italian wines.

I’ve investigated and reviewed many wine delivery services. I evaluated them based on variety, consistency, pricing, and customer feedback. Surprisingly, only 6 made the cut as the best Italian wine clubs by offering a good range of Italian bottles. 

Firstleaf stands out as my top choice for Italian wine delivery. Firstleaf tailors its wine selections to your unique palate, catering to various budget preferences. By delving into my list, you'll pinpoint a wine delivery service that aligns perfectly with your desires.

The Best Italian Wine Clubs Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best Overall Italian Wine Club

Firstleaf is my top pick for Italian wine. After scouring numerous clubs, it emerged as the standout for its robust offering of Italian varieties. Whether you're a seasoned wine enthusiast or new to the world of vino, Firstleaf offers something special.

The club is perfect for refining your wine palate. It uses personalized algorithms to match wines tailored to your preferences. This means you're more likely to discover Italian wines that suit your taste buds, making every sip a delightful experience.

You can secure high-quality Italian wines at competitive prices. For instance, for around $20, you can indulge in the award-winning rosé prosecco, Prima Foglia. This is a testament to Firstleaf’s commitment to balance quality with affordability.

The subscription model is flexible. You have the option to receive 6 bottles every 1, 2, or 3 months. This gives you the freedom to choose a pace that works best for you, ensuring you always have an Italian wine ready for any occasion.

The platform is user-friendly. Our expert reviewer found that selections can be easily browsed by color, grape, region, and more. This means that you can delve deeper into the intricacies of Italian wines, enhancing your overall experience.

There’s a vast selection in the catalog. At any given time, you can find around 20 different Italian wines in the Firstleaf shop. From robust reds to crisp whites, there's a bottle to suit every preference and occasion.

Firstleaf offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee meaning customer satisfaction is important. This shows the confidence in the wines it offers and ensures that you can explore its range of Italian wines with peace of mind.

Affordability is a key highlight with prices starting at $7.49. What's more, if you decide to order in bulk, shipping is free for 12 bottles or more. This not only saves you money but also ensures you have a steady stock of your favorite Italian picks.

2. Naked Wines – Best for Backing Boutique Wineries

Naked Wines champions boutique wineries. It's heartening to know that while enjoying your Italian wine, you're also supporting small-scale winemakers. These boutique wineries often produce unique and memorable flavors that stand out from mass-produced counterparts.

Being an Angel is like being an investor. When you become an Angel member with Naked Wines, you pay a monthly subscription. This isn't just a fee; it's a direct investment into the winemakers, helping them produce the best Italian wines possible.

You have the power to curate your wine box. One of the standout features is the ability for you to handpick and create a box filled with Italian favorites. This means every bottle delivered to your door resonates with your preferences.

The selection of Italian bottles is commendable. At present, there are over 20 Italian wines you can choose from. A notable mention is the crisp white Sacchetto delle Venezie Pinot Grigio, a popular choice among many Italian wine enthusiasts.

Angel membership comes with notable perks. Our reviewer tried the Angel membership for themselves and the benefits were evident. From exclusive offers to early access to new Italian wines, it's an experience worth indulging in.

Navigating its selection is a breeze. With a broad range of wines, it offers a filtering system that lets you sort by country, grape, style, and type. This makes it easier for you to zero in on Italian wines that match your taste.

Your reviews shape your future wine selections. The more Italian wines you review on the platform, the better tailored your future recommendations become. This ensures that over time, the wines you are recommended align even more closely with your palate.

Pricing is transparent and straightforward. The prices for bottles start at $7.99. The shipping costs, however, are dependent on your location. It's always best to check the final cost to ensure it aligns with your budget.

3. Wine Insiders – Best for Impressive Global Selections

Wine Insiders boasts a collection from around the world, emphasizing Italian favorites. In my exploration of its offerings, it became clear that it understands the charm and diversity of Italian vineyards. Whether you're a novice to Italian wines or a seasoned enthusiast, you're bound to find something that captures the essence of Italy's various wine regions.

Its selection includes over 40 distinct Italian bottles. This range offers a captivating journey through Italy's famous wine-producing regions. For you, this means a chance to experience not just the popular choices, but also some hidden gems that might not be on every wine enthusiast's radar yet.

Both red and white varieties are represented, from blends to single grape types. Sangiovese, a renowned red grape variety from central Italy, is available, as is Moscato, a favorite white grape known for its sweet and aromatic character. You'll find a rich tapestry of flavors, each bottle narrating a unique story from its origin.

Flexibility defines its wine club membership. When I delved into its membership details, it was clear that it prioritizes customer convenience and preferences. You can tailor your membership to suit your consumption patterns and taste, ensuring that every bottle you receive resonates with your palate.

Members receive a shipment every 12 weeks. You can opt for an all-red, all-white, or a mixed selection. This volume not only guarantees you a steady supply of quality wine but also offers a diverse tasting experience every month.

Martha Stewart's curated wines are a highlight. A notable example is the Italian Cala De' Poeti Maremma Toscana. This collaboration showcases Martha's impeccable taste and Wine Insiders' commitment to quality. When you open a bottle of Cala De' Poeti Maremma Toscana, you're indulging in a carefully chosen representation of Italian viticulture.

Its affordability truly impressed my colleague in their in-depth review. While exploring the various bottles and their price tags, they found that premium quality doesn't always come with a hefty price. For those of you who appreciate value for money, Wine Insiders will not disappoint.

Pricing starts at $8.99, and orders of 6 bottles or more come with complimentary shipping. This approach further underlines its commitment to offer value. By eliminating shipping costs for bulk orders, this ensures you can savor more of what Italy has to offer without the extra financial burden.

4.  Wine Awesomeness – Great for Exploring Themed Monthly Boxes

Wine Awesomeness sends themed boxes that impressed our reviewer. Each box tells a story with its handpicked Italian wine selection, inviting you to dive deep into the rich wine culture of Italy. It’s an experience that transports you straight to the beautiful vineyards of Tuscany, Piedmont, or Veneto.

You don’t undergo a quiz when you sign up. This is a refreshing approach, allowing you to step outside your wine comfort zone. You'll often find bottles that you might not have picked up on your own but end up loving. 

There are 3 membership tiers available: 3, 6, or 12 bottles. Depending on your drinking habits and whether you're sharing with family or friends, you can choose a tier that best suits your needs. Each box is designed to offer a broad perspective on global wines, regardless of the tier you opt for.

The selection spans from Italian prosecco to whites and reds. An interesting option is the Peach Bellini wine cocktail, a delightful fusion that embodies the spirit of Italian summer. It ensures that you get to taste not just the classics but also the innovative mixes that Italy has to offer.

Choose between a curated selection or handpick your wines. If you're someone who knows exactly what they want, dive into its collection and select your favorites. On the other hand, if you're looking to be surprised, let its experts curate a box that's bound to fascinate your palate.

Members enjoy a 20% discount in its shop. If you find a wine that you just can't get enough of, just head over to the online shop and stock up. As a member, you get the perk of purchasing your top wines at a reduced price, making it even more enticing to revisit those Italian favorites.

Managing your account is a breeze. If your preferences change, perhaps veering more towards reds or wishing to explore more proseccos, it’s easy to update your online profile. The flexibility ensures that your wine journey remains tailored to your evolving tastes.

Its pricing is transparent, starting at $13.25. Depending on where you live, expect your box to arrive within 1 to 7 days. The seamless integration of affordability, quality, and prompt delivery makes it a commendable choice for Italian wine enthusiasts like you.

5. Macy’s Wine Shop – Best for High-Quality, Affordable Selections

Macy's Wine Shop offers quality wines at affordable rates. Some Italian selections start from just $11 a bottle. As someone who constantly searches for value without compromising on quality, this pricing feels both competitive and fair. The wines showcase the breadth and depth of Italian winemaking, bringing forward both renowned and lesser-known regions.

The wines are exclusive and you won't find them on Macy's store shelves. It’s a unique offering, ensuring that as a subscriber, you're tasting selections that stand apart from the usual retail offerings. This exclusivity speaks to the curated experience it aims to deliver.

Every 12 weeks, subscribers receive 6 bottles of sommelier-selected wine. This quarterly adventure ensures you're constantly introduced to new flavors and profiles from Italy's diverse wine landscape. The frequency feels just right, giving you ample time to savor each bottle.

For those new to Italian wines, the "top rated" section is a good place to start. You can also check out our full review for more details on what you can expect to find on Macy’s wine list This section offers a curated list, ensuring you sample only the best.

With over 45 Italian bottles to choose from, the variety is vast. It encompasses reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling options like the bubbly prosecco (pictured above). The sheer range ensures that whether you’re hosting a dinner, enjoying a quiet evening, or celebrating a special occasion, there’s a bottle to match the moment.

Many wines are rated highly and priced under $20. It's always a pleasure to find wines that both taste great and are easy on the wallet. This, combined with the sheer diversity of offerings, highlights the value Macy’s Wine Shop brings to the table.

Not all items can ship to every state. This is something to be aware of when making your selection. It’s always best to check the shipping details to ensure that your chosen wines can indeed be delivered to your location. 

Starting at $10.99 you also get free shipping for 6 or more bottles. The bottles land on your doorstep in just 2 to 3 days, making it 1 of the faster delivery timelines I've encountered. It ensures that the anticipation of sipping on a new Italian wine doesn’t last long.

6. Winc – Best for Modern Wine Discoveries

Winc provides a selection of wines from various global regions. This collection, although vast and varied, does include Italian wines among its offerings. Given its global focus, you'll find that its Italian range is interspersed with wines from other parts of the world.

Winc's wine options rotate on a regular basis. This regular change in selection means that the wines available can vary from month to month. While Italian wines might be present in 1 month, the next could spotlight wines from a different region.

After you've set up your taste profile, Winc delivers 4 bottles a month. These are chosen based on your expressed preferences. It's a system intended to align with your palate, though it doesn't guarantee an Italian wine in every shipment. Read our full review to find out more on how Winc works.

Customization of your order is an option with Winc. If the initial selection doesn't feature the number of Italian bottles you were hoping for, adjustments can be made. This way, you can try to ensure more Italian wines in your monthly set.

When it comes to an extensive Italian variety, other platforms might be more suitable. While Winc has its merits, its Italian wine range is not its most pronounced feature. Firstleaf might be a more fitting choice if you're solely after Italian wines.

Winc includes a wine tasting guide with its orders. Our review touched upon this feature, noting that it provides information about the wines, though it doesn't exclusively cater to Italian wines.

Winc doesn't automatically send monthly orders. If you choose not to order in a given month, your credit carries over. It's a system that might benefit those who await specific wine rotations, including potential increases in Italian selections.

Winc has a set pricing structure with a monthly fee starting at $12.00. If a bottle doesn't meet your expectations, it offers a refund of credits, but always review its terms to understand the scope of this policy.

7. Plonk – Best for Natural Organic Wines

Plonk offers a great selection of organic and sustainable Italian wines. When it comes to authenticity, character, and pure taste, it's clear that Plonk prioritizes the finest organic wines. Sourced from sustainable vineyards across Italy, each bottle promises quality and integrity in every sip.

You can handpick your favorites in the shop. While you have the freedom to choose wines that suit your palate, it's essential to note that there's a minimum order of 6 bottles. This ensures you get a varied experience and the wines are well-protected during shipping. Check out our full review for more on the ordering process.

It has a special Italian wine 6-pack collection. This range showcases the richness of Italian wine styles. From the velvety reds of Tuscany to the crisp whites of Friuli, this collection gives you a snapshot of Italy's diverse wine regions.

Choose between mixed, red, or white wine club options. Plonk understands that every wine lover has a preference. Whether you're in the mood for a medley of flavors or you lean more towards reds or whites, there's a curated selection waiting for you.

Select from 4, 6, or 12 bottles for every shipment. Depending on how often you enjoy a glass or how many guests you're hosting, Plonk lets you decide the size of your wine delivery. This flexibility means you'll always have the perfect amount of wine at your disposal.

Sending a wine box as a gift subscription is an option. If you have friends or family who appreciate Italian wines as much as you do, Plonk lets you share the love. A wine box subscription makes for a thoughtful gift, introducing the recipient to a world of organic Italian wines.

Every order comes with delightful recipe pairing suggestions. There's an art to pairing wine with food, and Plonk ensures you master it. With each order, you receive recipe ideas, helping you create meals that elevate the taste of the wine and vice versa.

Plonk offers 2 payment methods to fit your budget and commitment level. Opt for monthly payments or pre-pay for an extended period. Prices start at a $9.50 and shipping is free for every order, provided you meet the 6-bottle minimum.

8. Gold Medal Wine Club – Best for Award-Winning Vintages

The Gold Medal Wine Club offers a distinct selection of Italian wines. For those interested in Italian vintages, it's noteworthy to mention this club's dedication to curating quality choices. Over the years, it has gained a reputation for sourcing some commendable wines.

It has various membership tiers available. Particularly, the International Club tends to focus on wines from Italy's renowned regions, offering a direct connection to Italian viticulture.

You have the flexibility to choose 3, 6, or 12 bottles per shipment. Read our full review for all the details on how the club works. Depending on your preference, there's an option that can match your consumption or exploration pace. 

It often sources wines from boutique wineries. These wines are not only notable in quality but also in their distinctiveness. It's evident that a considerable number of its selections come from smaller vineyards across Italy.

The emphasis on small-scale wineries is evident. Much like other platforms like Naked Wines, it prioritizes wines from artisans. These wines often capture the essence of Italian tradition and the dedication of their producers.

Its shop offers a curated selection. While the range might not be as extensive as some other clubs, the focus here is on quality. The wines chosen for inclusion typically offer an authentic Italian taste experience.

Regarding the shop's interface, I find Firstleaf’s filtering system to be more user-friendly. Navigating the shop can be a bit of a learning curve due to its setup. Yet, with some patience, the available Italian wines are worth the exploration.

Prices start from $9.50 with a 2 bottle minimum order. While the club does prioritize quality, its pricing remains in a reasonable range. But do note that starting your order requires at least 2 bottles.

9. Wine Library – Best for Expert Curated Choices

Wine Library is a renowned wine retailer based in New Jersey. It has earned a reputation for its extensive collection of wines and its dedication to educating customers. As an Italian wine enthusiast, you'll find it an invaluable resource in your exploration of the region's vino.

The shop boasts over 400 Italian bottles. Ranging from the very affordable $5 to the luxurious $879.99, Wine Library ensures that you have a plethora of options, whether you're a novice or a connoisseur.

The Gary Vee Monthly Wine Club is a highlight. Joining this club means immersing yourself in a world where wines are hand-picked by experts, ensuring you get to sample the best Italian wines without the guesswork.

It champions an educational approach to wine. Detailed notes accompany each wine, and tasting videos further enrich your experience. You won't just be sipping wine; you'll be learning the history, process, and nuances behind each bottle.

Online wine events are frequently on the agenda. Participating in these events allows you to connect with fellow wine enthusiasts, share experiences, and discover new Italian wines that might soon become your favorites.

Alongside your chosen Italian wine, you can also order spirits, beers, and gourmet food items. Think of complementing your wine with curated cheeses and meats, elevating your tasting experience.

Be mindful of the shipping restrictions. It's essential to note that Wine Library doesn't ship to all states. Always check the shipping policies to ensure you can receive your chosen Italian wines without any hitches. For shipping to Alaska or Hawaii, try Firstleaf.

Affordability is a strong suit and prices start as low as $5 a bottle. If you're an avid wine enthusiast, consider purchasing a Library Pass. This pass guarantees you free shipping for a year, making your Italian wine journey seamless and cost-effective.

 Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Italian Wine Clubs

When researching Italian wine clubs, I prioritized specific criteria to pinpoint the most reliable options.

• Diversity of selection: A broad wine selection allows a more comprehensive exploration of Italy's wine regions. In reviewing various clubs, Naked Wines consistently provided wines from a range of independent producers.

• Flexibility of subscriptions: Not everyone wants a long-term commitment, so flexible terms are beneficial. In this regard, Macy’s Wine Shop offers a range of subscription adjustments to suit different needs.

• Tasting notes and education: Knowledge about the wine you're drinking can enhance the experience. Wine Awesomeness provides detailed tasting notes with each of its monthly selections, offering a balance of information and discovery.

• Personalization options: Everyone has a unique palate, so a 1-size-fits-all approach doesn't always work. Firstleaf stood out for its emphasis on understanding and adjusting to individual taste preferences.

FAQ

What is an Italian wine club?

An Italian wine club offers curated Italian wine deliveries on a subscription basis. These clubs, such as Macy's Wine Shop, allow you to explore a range of wines from different Italian regions without needing to travel. By subscribing, you receive handpicked wines, often accompanied by tasting notes.

What’s the best Italian wine club? 

The "best" wine club varies based on personal preferences. However, Firstleaf stands out for its exceptional personalization options and dedication to tailoring wine selections to individual tastes. Its curated lists ensure that members receive wines suited to their palate.

Can I choose the Italian wines in my shipment?

Many wine clubs allow members to customize their shipments. For instance, Wine Awesomeness provides thematic monthly collections, but also offers flexibility in wine selection, giving you the power to tailor your deliveries based on personal preferences or desired exploration.

How do wine clubs ensure Italian wine quality?

Wine clubs collaborate directly with vineyards and employ wine experts. This guarantees the quality of selections. Naked Wines, for example, supports independent winemakers, ensuring that you receive authentic, high-quality Italian wines sourced directly from passionate producers.

Best Italian Wine Clubs in 2024 — Final Score