10 Best Wine Delivery NYC 2024: Pro Picks and Tips

NYC has some of the best food in the world, but finding the perfect wine pairing isn’t easy. Picking from the best wine delivery NYC has to offer isn't easy, as there appear to be way too many options. But fret not – I’m here to guide you through the very best options for this year.

Fortunately, I’ve done the groundwork for you and have come up with 10 great picks. These wine delivery services will feature all types of wines from many regions throughout the world at varying price points. Whether you like spicy reds, refreshing whites, exciting bubblies, or sweet dessert wines, this list has you covered.

Overall, my top pick this year is Firstleaf for several reasons. It offers a personalized wine selection algorithm based on a 13-question quiz about your taste preferences. Also, you get a unique wine-tasting experience thanks to its vast selection of over 300 award-winning wines from lesser-known regions. This seamlessly balances quality and affordability.

The 10 Best Wine Delivery NYC Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best High-Quality Wines

Firstleaf is a source for over 300 unique, top-ranking wines sourced from around the globe. It even features a few wines from lesser-known regions like Greece and Chile. This approach enables access to both high-grade and cost-effective wine alternatives.

It has developed a clever system to ensure that the wines it delivers are to your liking. It all starts with a straightforward 13-question quiz to discern your taste preferences. Depending on your responses, Firstleaf handpicks 6 wines and sends them to you every 1 to 3 months.

In my evaluation, I was impressed by how it employs a thumbs-up or thumbs-down rating system to customize your future wine shipments. To gain further insights, check out our comprehensive Firstleaf review.

Firstleaf commits to catering to your unique taste preferences while still maintaining quality. The site claims that the company samples 10,000 different wines from all over the world to bring you only the very best options.

For novices or those wishing to broaden their wine knowledge, Firstleaf has a 'Wine School'. It's chock-full of informative articles that help you understand the various types of wine.

If you want to give a gift, Firstleaf offers electronic gift cards ranging from $25-$200. While it does not allow sending of custom boxes, you can help someone get started with a starter box.

Your initial box is shipped free of charge, but future orders incur a $9.95 shipping fee. Deliveries are made via UPS Ground or FedEx Ground, and your wine typically arrives 2-5 days after shipping. Moreover, Firstleaf ensures all its deliveries are carbon-neutral.

Excellent customer service is a high priority for Firstleaf. It extends a 100% satisfaction guarantee and a Wine Concierge service. This basically lets you talk to someone about your taste preferences or ask any questions about your order or delivery.

The service kicks off at $7.49 per bottle, a balance of affordability and quality. While it may not be the most economical wine delivery option, in my experience, you’re getting your money's worth. However, if you are in pursuit of an even more budget-friendly option, Wine Insiders could be an alternative to consider.

2. Naked Wines – Best Wines From Small Independent Vineyards

At Naked Wines, you have the opportunity to fill your cart with a variety of wines you fancy, rather than waiting for a monthly shipment. Some services only offer curated wins that you can’t pick yourself. Our Naked Wines review provides more insights into this approach. 

An individualized recommendation system exists to guide you in choosing wines that match your preferences. As you continue to purchase and review wines, it refines its suggestions to align with your tastes.

The wine selection at Naked Wines is varied and frequently updated. However, it predominantly offers standard reds and whites. Remember, it isn't possible to order a single bottle – rather, your order needs to be a case of at least 6 bottles. If you need individual bottles, consider Firstleaf instead.

Wines at Naked Wines are globally sourced, with a significant percentage from the US. There are also exquisite options from renowned wine-producing nations like Australia, France, Spain, and Chile. You can leverage the intuitive filtering system to find the exact wine to suit your palate.

Naked Wines' "Angel" allows you to support independent winemakers with a monthly subscription. This payment, in turn, gives you access to wines at wholesale prices. The membership costs $40 and can be canceled anytime.

Plus, this $40 is a credit toward your future wine purchases – it’s not just a “fee”. Being an "Angel" earns you exclusive wines, discounts, a free bottle each month, and invitations to special tasting events.

Each bottle displays 2 prices: an "Angels" price and another for non-members. The discounted "Angel" price, typically 20 to 30% lower than the non-member price, is your benefit for funding new wine production.

If you’re sending a gift box, the packaging is standard, and a gift message can be included. The recipient must confirm they are of legal drinking age upon delivery. That means a government-issued and valid photo ID card must be presented on delivery.

Since the wines are packaged in bulk, single-bottle orders are not available. You'll need to purchase at least 6 bottles, setting your minimum expenditure at $60, even for a $10 wine deal. Prices begin at $7.99 per bottle.

A shipping charge of $9.99 applies, but orders above $100 ship for free. Deliveries reach most states between 1 and 4 days, excluding Ohio. You must be present to accept the delivery and verify you're over 21. Keep in mind that Naked Wines also offers convenient options such as workplace delivery or local pickup.

3. Vinesse – Best Selection and Variety

Vinesse's aim is to deliver unique wines from intimate vineyards straight to your dining room. These aren't the wines you'd typically find in nearby stores. Esteemed magazines like Self and Conde Nast Traveler have sung its praises.

Signing up for Vinesse's club is a breeze. All you have to do is choose your favorite wine type, specify if the membership is intended as a gift, and input your delivery and payment information. Then, you'll join an exclusive club that provides access to remarkable global wines. Learn more about Vinesse’s wine clubs in our official review.

Vinesse offers 14 separate clubs to accommodate a wide range of tastes. For instance, the "Light & Sweet" club is perfect for fans of mild wines. The "World of Wine" club will suit you if you're a wine enthusiast seeking new experiences. If American wines are more your style, consider the "American Cellars" club.

As a club member, you have complete control over your wine selection. You determine the variety of wines included in your order, whether it's strictly reds, only whites, or a mix of both, Vinesse is at your service.

Once you join, Vinesse treats you to a sampler of 8 wines for $49.99. This gives you a preview of what Vinesse has in store for you. Then, every 5 to 7 weeks, a new selection of wines is delivered to you.

The cost of each shipment depends on the club you've selected. The pricing typically starts at $10.00 per order. There aren't any membership fees – you only pay for the wine you receive.

Vinesse ensures your wines are carefully packed to prevent any damage during transit. You have the liberty to choose whether your wines are delivered to your house or your office. If you're not home when the delivery is made, you can pick up your wines from a nearby FedEx location.

4. Bright Cellars – Best Wine Personalization Quiz

With Bright Cellars, a range of wines from around the world comes right to your door. It brings you wines from small, unique vineyards, giving you the chance to try all kinds of flavors. You could try anything from traditional grape wines to unusual varietals that taste like apple, watermelon, or even chocolate.

It has a range of wines to fit any taste, whether you like them sweet and fruity or dry and strong. If you're not sure what you want, you can take a fun quiz on Bright Cellars to find out what you might like. For more info on Bright Cellars’ personalization quiz, check out our review.

No matter what the occasion is, you’ll find a wine that works. Whether a wedding or just a glass of wine in your backyard, there’s something for everyone. It even tells you more about each wine, like the best temperature to serve it at and how strong it is.

Bright Cellars offers a bunch of different wine bundles. But you can't choose individual bottles or mix wines from different bundles. If you want to pick and choose more freely, you might like Wine Awesomeness better.

When you sign up with Bright Cellars, you get extra goodies like reward points and bonuses for getting your friends to sign up. To find the best wines for you, all you have to do is take the quiz. Your answers help Bright Cellars figure out what wines you might like and suggest them just for you.

Once you've done the quiz, you can choose your box of wines and check out. Your wines come in a cardboard box with special cards that tell you about each wine.

Bright Cellars keeps things interesting by offering new wines every month. It also shows off its best wines. Right now, for instance, it's featuring the 2021 Pinot Grigio, 2021 Merlot, and 2021 Montepulciano. These wines come from California and are part of different bundles.

After you order, your wines are usually shipped in 2 to 4 business days. You'll get tracking info for your package. Just remember, someone over 21 has to be there to sign for the delivery with a valid ID. Finally, the cost starts at $10.00 per bottle.

5. Wine Insiders – Best Affordable Wines

Wine Insiders is a name you might have heard about for its wide selection of affordable wines. You may even know it because of celebrity curations, like those by Martha Stewart.

The majority of its wines are priced under $20 and sourced from across the world. This makes it an excellent platform to widen your wine-tasting experience. You can dive deeper by checking out my detailed review of Wine Insiders.

The wine categories it offers are pretty vast. Options range from reds, whites, and sparkling to rosé and even dessert wines. These wines trace their roots back to numerous countries, including Argentina, Australia, Austria, Chile, France, Italy, Hungary, Mexico, Morocco, New Zealand, Portugal, Spain, South Africa, and the U.S.

With around 100 wine varieties on display, Wine Insiders ensures an ample selection. At times, it features a 1-of-a-kind wine from a specific winemaker. Even though it might not host certain well-known labels, I found the selection to be quite impressive overall. You'll also find unique offerings like organic and vegan wines, canned wines, and even cocktails.

It boasts a variety of wines, many of which score more than 90 and are priced under $20. However, if you're in search of vintage or ultra-luxury wines, this might not be your ideal place. But an example of a top-rated wine under $20 is the 2020 Marquis de Bacalon Bordeaux Blanc, which boasts a perfect 5-star rating based on 6 reviews.

Every bottle's detailed information is available for your review on the website, including details about the winery, variety, vintage, alcohol content, country, and region. It offers 6 different wine set categories with varying prices and sizes, which include Magnum sets as well.

For those interested in getting regular deliveries, it provides a subscription service. You can get a shipment of 12 bottles every 12 weeks and choose between white, red, or a mix of both. Your first delivery will also include 3 bonus bottles and a special wine accessory gift with certain deliveries.

Starting at $8.99, the prices are quite reasonable with standard bottles going up to around $25. Magnum wine sets begin at $35 for a single bottle and can go up to approximately $47 per bottle for a case of 6. You can get even better deals by using the discount code Get 10% off + FREE shipping!.

6. The California Wine Club – Best US Wines

California Wine Club started out by only featuring wines from California. Nowadays, it offers wines from as far as the Pacific Northwest and beyond. By supporting this club, you're also helping small family-owned wineries. If you're curious about this, my co-worker has written a detailed review.

This club has a large selection of wines, whether red or white. If you’re more into reds, It has rich flavors like Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Pinot Noir, and Zinfandel, just to list some.

If you prefer white wines, it also has lots of choices. For instance, you can grab bottles like Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio, and Riesling, among others. It has carefully chosen each wine to make sure it's of the best quality and taste.

The club has different monthly wine clubs that cater to various preferences. If you like well-known wines that are made in limited amounts, you might enjoy the Signature Series club.

If you like the variety of wine regions in California, the Premier Series club is for you. It offers award-winning wines that might be perfect for you.

For those who love small-batch artisan wines, the Aged Cabernet Series club is a good fit. This club focuses on Cabernet Sauvignon wines aged between 8-12 years. If you want to try wines from different parts of the world, the International Selections club gives you the chance to do just that.

In addition, the club has a unique Pacific Northwest Series club. This club focuses on great wines from Oregon and Washington State, areas that are known for their cool-climate varietals.

Being a member also comes with a lot of benefits. From detailed tasting notes and access to the club's magazine to discounts on future orders and the ability to customize your shipments, California Wine Club promises a great journey of wine discovery.

With prices starting at $10.99 per bottle, it also has gift options. There are 4 categories to choose from: Wine Club Gifts, Wine Gift Sets, Business Wine Gifts, and Electronic Gift Certificates.

7. Wine Awesomeness – Best Wine Information

Wine Awesomeness is a service that wants to help you try new wines each month. It wants you to not just stick to wines you know but to try new types that will make your wine tasting experience better. It curates wine boxes for you to try that you may not have had before. Learn more in my colleague’s more detailed review.

"The Back Label" magazine is an educational and informative digital wine publication. I personally found it useful. It's full of information and advice about wine and everything that goes with it. Whether you're a wine expert or a beginner, I think you'll find it useful.

Wine Awesomeness has 2 main subscription plans. You can get 3 bottles for $49 or 6 bottles for $79. Both come with free shipping, which makes them pretty affordable.

Every month's wines have a special theme to keep things interesting. In the past, they've had themes like a focus on French wines, a highlight of rosé wines, and choices that go well with a barbecue.

It has a variety of wines, including red, white, sparkling, rosé, and organic. It also has canned options. Some collections are associated with people and institutions you may be aware of. For example, you can pick from collections like Opopop, Shannon St. Clair, Nail Betch, and Emily Post.

Besides the monthly subscriptions, Wine Awesomeness also has an a la carte online store. This lets you buy single wines, so you can try wines that aren't in your monthly box. I always like having the option to order single items.

It also has a "mystery" wine option if you like surprises. For a fixed price, you'll get a surprise bottle of wine. It could be red, white, rosé, or sparkling – so I recommend using this at your own risk. However, buying any new wine, whether in-person or online is always a risk.

Wine Awesomeness rates each wine out of 5 to help subscribers pick wines. This makes it easy to see which wines are most liked. But, right now, it doesn't let users write their own reviews, which could give more insight into the wines.

It also has a range of gift options. It has gift boxes that are themed around different wine selections, and the boxes come in different sizes for different events. This makes giving wine as a gift much simpler and fun. Pricing starts at $13.25.

8. Macy’s Wine Shop – Best Exclusive, Small-Batch wines

At Macy's Wine Club, you can buy single bottles, or you can sign up for the free club. If you join the club, every 3 months you'll get to try 6 different wines from all around the globe.

If you keep your membership for the whole year, you'll get a special bonus. You'll get 2 extra wine deliveries – 1 during the cold winter and another in the hot summer.

Macy's Wine Club has 4 types of wine: red, white, rosé, and sparkling. There are more red wines than the others. The red wines are strong and include types like Cabernet Franc, Montepulciano, Petite Sirah, and Sangiovese. You can drink these reds with dinner or just sip them on their own.

The white wines at Macy's Wine Club are just as good. You can choose from light and refreshing wines like Chardonnay, Muscadet, Moscato, or Pinot Grigio, among others. The wines come from all over the world. Some are from Portugal, others from Chile, France, the United States, and more.

Macy's Wine Club also puts together groups of wines for different tastes. One cool group is the Sommelier's Choice, which includes wines that wine experts really like. If you're into vegan or organic wines, you're in luck – these are also offered.

When you're a member of Macy's Wine Club, you get special treats. You can try rare wines that aren't made in big batches. Every wine also comes with notes that tell you more about it, which can make drinking it more fun and interesting. Find out more in our full Macy’s Wine Shop review.

Macy's Wine Club also has sets of wines that you can buy. These sets can have 3, 6, or 12 bottles in them, and they make great gifts. The gift sets include Luxe Gifts, budget-friendly Wine Sets, and Wedding Wines. You can also look at other groups of wines like Essential Wines, Easy-Drinking Reds, and Award Winners.

9. Monthly Clubs – Best Rare Boutique Wines

The Monthly Wine Club lets you taste wines from all over the world every month. You can try different types of wines, including red, white, and sometimes even sparkling varieties. 

You can also try a fairly respectable number of different wines. For example, you might get to try wines like Sangiovese, Pinot Bianco, Riesling, the dark Merlot, the all-rounder Pinot Noir, the strong Shiraz, and more. To find out more, check out our expert review.

The wines you get aren't just chosen at random. The club has wine experts, called sommeliers, who select the best-tasting wines. The list of wines includes special bottles like S. Sebastião Vinho Regional Lisboa Syrah/Touriga Nacional Reserva 2020 and Herdade Aldeia de Cima Serra do Mendro Alentejo Reserva Tinto 2019.

You have the choice of joining 4 different monthly wine clubs: The Premier Series, The Bold Reds, The Masters Series, and The Collectors Series. Each month, you can expect 2 special bottles from the club you choose. You can decide between rare red or white wines, typically sourced from highly-respected wineries.

Every wine also comes with a card that gives you more information about it. These cards tell you where the wine is from, what it tastes like, and what foods it goes well with. It's like having your own wine expert to help you enjoy each glass.

Being a member of the club is also a fun way to learn about wines. You'll start to pick up on the small differences in taste and learn how wines from different places can taste unique. It's like going on a food and drink adventure without leaving your house.

If you're worried about being tied down, the Club has ways for you to make it fit your needs. You can choose how long you want to be a member, whether that's a few months or a whole year. You can also pick what kinds of wines you want to try, like if you prefer red wines or want to try wines from certain parts of the world.

10. Wine Library – Best Wine, Beer, and Liquor Selection

Wine Library is a shop where you can find a wide range of wines and other drinks from all over the world. It's not your regular wine club – rather, It's more like a liquor store where you can pick any drink you like that fits your budget.

You'll find all sorts of wines here from red to white to sparkling and even rosé. If you're not sure what to choose, it offers helpful categories like “Best $20 to $30 wines” and “90+ rated wines”. This way, you can get great quality wines without spending a fortune (though it also carries pricier options if that's what you're after).

The wine selection at Wine Library comes from many places. You'll see wines from Spain, Italy, Portugal, the US, France, Argentina, and more. So, if you like different types of red and white wines like Chardonnay, Merlot, Pinot Grigio, Pinot Noir, and more, it probably has it all.

Wine Library also helps you learn about wine. On its website, it provides lots of information about each wine's taste, smell, and unique features. This helps you make the best choice for you.

You might be also interested in the huge backlog of reviews, tastings, and other videos. You can find these on Wine Library TV, where the host talks about wines you can get directly from Wine Library. This is a great way to get a sense of what bottles are like before you order.

One of the best parts of Wine Library is that it tries to learn about what you like. If you join any of its email lists, it will send you deals, discounts, and wine recommendations that you might like. Plus, it gives you ideas for other drinks.

Wine Library also has all kinds of wine-related tools and gadgets. Whether you need glasses, jugs, bottle openers, or tools to keep your wine fresh, you can find it here.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Wine Delivery NYC

Here's what I kept in mind when choosing the top services this year. These points might be helpful for you when deciding:

• Variety: Aim for a service offering an array of wines from various regions, both local and international. This aspect is crucial if you enjoy exploring diverse flavors or wish to sample unfamiliar wines. At a minimum, go for a service that showcases wines from your favorite regions such as South Africa, New Zealand, Europe, or the US.

• Excellence: While variety is excellent, the quality is equally significant. Seek a service that sources wines from top-tier vineyards and producers. Use customer feedback and ratings to verify this aspect.

• Prompt and reliable shipping: Consider the speed and dependability of the service's delivery. This factor becomes particularly vital if you're purchasing for a special occasion or gathering. Always look into what previous customers have to say about this.

• Pricing and value: Assess whether the service offers value for money. This involves comparing the wine prices, delivery fees, and any additional costs. It's also beneficial to see if they offer subscription plans or provide discounts for bulk purchases.

FAQ

Can you have wine delivered to NYC?

Yes, numerous online wine delivery services cater to NYC. But not all companies offer the same quality. This year, I suggest opting for Firstleaf due to its vast array of esteemed wines. Plus, it customizes your orders according to your individual tastes.

What are the best wine delivery clubs in NYC?

Naked Wines is among my favorite NYC wine delivery clubs. It has a great variety of wines from independent vineyards. Since your membership directly supports small wineries, Naked Wines is a good service to join if you like exploring new and unique bottles.

How does a wine club work?

Its method is to offer subscribers regular wine deliveries, either monthly or quarterly. There are subscription fees, but as part of the deal, subscribers receive a carefully chosen collection of wines. Frequently, these come with descriptions of the flavors and suggestions for matching with food. For this year, my recommendation goes to Vinesse.

Best Wine Delivery NYC in 2024 — Final Score