10 Best Wine Clubs 2024: The Creme de la Creme

In today's market, choosing the right wine club can be challenging. There are many wine delivery options available, but finding the 1 that is best suited to your tastes and preferences can be tough. That’s why I’m here to help you narrow down your choices.

I’ve done rigorous research and evaluation of many wine clubs. I’ve looked at criteria like wine selection, customization options, pricing, reliability, and customer service. And after extensive study, I’ve found the 10 best wine clubs for 2024.

Firstleaf is my top recommendation. Its prices are very competitive, and I was very impressed by its selection of award-winning wines and its excellent customer service. But every wine club on this list has something to offer wine lovers. Read on to find the best wine club for your needs! 

The Best Wine Clubs Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best Wine Club in 2024

Firstleaf offers great wines from around the globe at budget-friendly prices. Firstleaf sends members premium, high-quality wines from all over the world at affordable prices. For example, the Premium Pinot Noir Bundle pictured above has award-winning wines from France, Chile, and California.  

A 13-question tasting quiz helps determine your palate preferences. Firstleaf uses this information to tailor its recommendations to your tastes. You can also give the wines you receive a thumbs-up or a thumbs-down rating, which helps Firstleaf further sharpen its algorithm and improve its accuracy.

You also get complimentary consultations from Firstleaf’s Wine Concierge service. Knowledgeable experts can provide you with recommendations for wines you’ll love. It’s like having your own personal sommelier on call. And if you have a problem with your order or delivery delays, your Concierge can help you with those too.

Our expert reviewer was also very impressed by the Wine School section of Firstleaf’s website. It includes articles on winemaking, pairings, varietals, and more, catering to both novice and seasoned wine enthusiasts. And Firstleaf offers it free of charge to everybody, not just Firstleaf subscribers!

You’ll find a good variety of domestic and international favorites. There are a lot of popular varietals, like Cabernet Sauvignon, but also some less familiar grapes that’ll be a welcome and educational change of pace. You’ll also find wines from less famous but still fabulous wine-producing regions like Chile and South Africa.

Many of Firstleaf’s selections have won awards from wine competitions and publications. You’ll find more award-winning wines on Firstleaf than at any other wine club. But despite the high quality of these wines, Firstleaf manages to bring them to customers at very reasonable prices, with most wines coming in at $15 to $30 a bottle.

Firstleaf is also a great place to find gifts for wine-loving friends, colleagues, and family. You’ll find wine bottles for almost every occasion. And if you’re still not sure what to get, you can always order an E-Gift card for $25 to $200.

Firstleaf prices start at $7.49 per bottle, with a 6-bottle minimum on all orders. Subscribers get a 30% discount on all orders, and there’s a 100% satisfaction guarantee on every bottle.

2. Naked Wines – Best Wine Club for Independent Wineries

Naked Wines works directly with independent wineries, bypassing retail channels. This approach not only saves you money. It supports smaller vineyards and ensures a diverse and unique wine selection for its customers.

As a member of the Naked Wines Angel program, you contribute to the growth and sustainability of independent and family-owned vineyards. Angel members invest $40 monthly, which is used to nurture lesser-known wineries. You can learn more in our expert Naked Wines review.

In return, Angel members get a $40 credit deposited into their Naked Wines account. Members can use those credits to purchase wines at the time of ordering. There’s no subscription involved. You order wines when you need them and aren’t bound to a regular schedule. 

Experts from Naked Wines sample thousands of wines from hundreds of vineyards each month. Of the wines they test, only 5% are selected. This extensive and rigorous testing process ensures that only the best wines, representing a range of styles and regions, make it to the Naked Wines catalog.

Each wine on the menu features ratings and reviews from other customers. This is very useful for exploring new wines and helping you make informed choices. With nearly 400 wines on the menu, finding the best ones can be daunting. Reviews from your fellow customers are beneficial in making the right selection.

Angel members gain access to the Naked Wines message board. There, you not only get a chance to communicate with your fellow wine enthusiasts, but you can talk to Naked Wines staff and even chat with some of the winemakers who are supported by your Angel contributions.

You can use a wide range of filters to sort by location, varietal, vintage, and other factors. This may be confusing at first for newcomers, which is why Naked Wines lets you sort by style. For example, if you like red wines, you can look for a fruity, rich, or crisp red. This simplifies the selection process and makes it easier to learn about new wines.

Naked Wines prices begin at $7.99 per bottle, with a 6-bottle minimum. Angel members receive discounts of up to 60% on their purchases.

3. Vinesse – Best for Wines at All Price Points

Vinesse focuses on handcrafted wines from smaller wineries. With over 2 decades of experience in the wine industry, Vinesse has consistently provided a broad selection of excellent wines for wine lovers of every budget and experience level.

Each order comes with comprehensive tasting notes. Pairing wines with food is an art in itself, and Vinesse’s detailed notes will help you become a master at it. Whether you’re new to the world of wines or a seasoned connoisseur, Vinesse has offerings for all levels of wine enthusiasts.

Vinesse offers a range of membership choices, including both 1-time wine boxes and ongoing subscriptions. This flexibility caters to both occasional buyers and those looking for a regular supply of quality wines. It also gives you a chance to try Vinesse for yourself before committing to a subscription.

Most of Vinesse's wine selection is sourced from renowned US regions, supplemented by about 30% by international offerings. There are wines ranging from less than $15 a bottle and premium bottles that cost over $75. Our reviewer was highly impressed by the quality and variety of wines on offer at Vinesse.

Vinesse also stands out with its gift cards, subscriptions, and wine bundles, making it an excellent choice for presents. Whether it's for a special occasion or a simple gesture of appreciation, Vinesse's options can suit various gifting needs​​. All Vinesse orders are shipped in recyclable packaging, and many Vinesse wines are produced using sustainable farming.

You should be aware that while you can select red, white, or mixed subscription boxes, you can’t choose the bottles you get with your order. But if you like a bottle Vinesse sends, you get discounts when you order more from the wine shop.

You can select from 3, 4, 6, 8, or 12 bottles for each shipment and choose deliveries every 1, 2, or 3 months​​. Prices start at $10.00 per bottle. Unlike most wine delivery services, Vinesse has no minimum order. But you will pay a $16 shipping and $5 handling fee on orders of less than 12 bottles.

4. Bright Cellars – Best Wine Club Palate Profile Quiz

Bright Cellars stands out for its wine matching system. It uses a detailed but quick and easy quiz to pinpoint your wine preferences. In addition to questions about wines, it asks about your taste in tea, candy, and other foods. This approach ensures that the wines you receive are personalized to your palate preferences.

Every Bright Cellars wine is tested and rated by a team of wine experts, including a certified sommelier. The team provides detailed data on the wine’s sweetness, body, tannins, and more. The algorithm matches the data with your quiz results to find wines that are best suited to your palate.

The online shop is user-friendly and easy to navigate. You’ll have no trouble finding the exact type of wine you’re looking for. Cabernet Sauvignon lovers will be impressed by the Cab Collection Bundle pictured above, which gives you a sampling of great reds in a 4-bottle or 8-bottle package.

Wine novices will also appreciate the wine education section on the Bright Cellars website. There’s lots of informative content, put together in a well-organized and easy-to-follow fashion. With each wine, you get a wine-tasting card that provides information about alcohol percentage, pairings, and recommended serving temperature.

While you can purchase wine bundles a la carte, you can’t choose individual bottles. This setup introduces you to new wines, but those who prefer buying single bottles or choosing their own bundles may find it limiting. But our reviewer was impressed by the accuracy of the Bright Cellars algorithm so you don’t have to worry too much about its suggestions.

In addition to its wines, Bright Cellars offers a selection of margarita bundles. Margaritas are a popular party option and are also great for those who want to switch up their wines with something different. The margaritas arrive fully prepared, so all you need is a glass with a salted rim, and you’re ready to roll.

Prices start at $10.00 per bottle. Bright Cellars offers 4, 6, or 12-bottle subscriptions, and subscribers get a 20% discount on all wine bundles at the store.

5. Wine Insiders – Best Wine Club for Inexpensive Wines 

Wine Insiders is an ideal choice for wine lovers seeking a variety of affordable wines. There are many wines under $20, and you can even get wines for less than $6 per bottle in your first shipment​​. And for even more savings, you get free shipping on all orders of 6 or more bottles.

You get comprehensive details about every bottle, including its background and tasting notes. This level of detail enriches the wine-tasting experience, allowing you to appreciate the nuances and history behind each bottle. You can view all available wines before signing up to ensure that Wine Insiders meets your preferences before committing to a subscription.

Wine Insiders prides itself on its curated selection, offering both exclusive and award-winning wines backed by a 100% satisfaction guarantee​​. The curatorial team at Wine Insiders, with over 50 years of combined wine experience, meticulously reviews each wine. Only 3% of the wines sampled are accepted.

Wine Insiders also offers organic, vegan, and canned wine options. Whether you're looking for eco-friendly choices or convenient canned wines for on-the-go enjoyment, Wine Insiders has options to suit​​​​. Our reviewer noted that while Wine Insiders offers low prices, it still brings you a great selection of wines.

You’ll find Martha Stewart-curated wines at Wine Insiders. If you still miss the now-shuttered Martha Stewart Wine Club, you can still take advantage of Martha’s personal touch. The Martha’s Romantic Reds bundle pictured above is an example of what you can expect from her Wine Insiders collaboration.

The Live Chat feature at Wine Insiders provides immediate access to support staff in case of any issues with your order. Available Monday through Sunday, including weekends, this service provides prompt and efficient resolution of any queries or concerns​​.

Wine Insiders subscribers get 3, 4, 6, or 12 bottles delivered every 2 months. You can also order a la carte, with a 3-bottle minimum per order. Prices start at $8.99 per bottle.

6. The California Wine Club – Best Artisan Wines from California & Beyond

The California Wine Club is a superb choice for California wine enthusiasts. For over 30 years, it has showcased some of the Golden State’s most exciting and unique wines, with some great bottles from the Pacific Northwest and even a few international offerings as well. Founders Bruce and Pam Boring maintain a personal touch in its selections.

Each month, members receive hand-selected wines from different small, family-run vineyards. This approach not only supports lesser-known wineries but also provides a constantly evolving wine experience. You can learn more about The California Wine Club’s offerings in our detailed review. 

There are 6 different clubs to choose from. The Case Club series offers cases at $14 per bottle, while the Aged Cabernet Club features cabernets for over $100 each. Above, you see a sample of wines available in the popular Signature Series. This club sends 2, 3, or 4 award-winning wines which come in at around $45-60 a bottle,

The club’s magazine, Uncorked, gives you tasting tips, food pairings, and recipes. It’s an excellent resource for members who want to enhance their wine knowledge and experience. And if you’re planning to visit California, Uncorked also alerts you to upcoming tastings and VIP events at participating wineries.

Gift options include wine subscriptions, gift cards, or eGift certificates. The California Wine Club also offers branded corporate gifts. Whether you’re looking to share the gift of wine for personal or professional reasons, The California Wine Club has you covered.

Monthly, bimonthly, or quarterly delivery options are available, and you can choose red, white, or mixed boxes. Prices start at $10.99 per bottle. If you ever find yourself unimpressed with a bottle you receive, The California Wine Club guarantees they’ll replace it.

7. Wine Awesomeness – Great Mystery Wines

Wine Awesomeness is on a mission to bring you exceptional wines. With its focus on wines that not only taste great but also have intriguing backstories, it ensures each monthly delivery is a unique experience.

Wine Awesomeness boasts an impressive international wine list, featuring over 150 wines each month. All wines arrive with tasting notes and recipe ideas. This comprehensive approach makes it an excellent choice for those looking to expand their wine knowledge.

For regular wine deliveries, joining the Discovery Wine Club is a smart move. You can choose between a 3-bottle and a 6-bottle membership. Both plans include wine cellar access, free delivery, and a 20% discount on wine reorders.

The Back Label, a digital magazine available on the Wine Awesomeness website, is a treasure trove of information. It covers topics related to wine and the wine lifestyle, including recipes and interviews with chefs, sommeliers, and people in the industry. You don’t have to be a subscriber or even a customer to take advantage of the information Wine Awesomeness provides.

Wine Awesomeness also offers multiple wine bundle options, catering to different preferences and occasions. This flexibility allows you to tailor your wine experience to your specific tastes and needs​​. The Red, Red Wine 3-Pack pictured above brings you wines from South Australia, Washington State, and Salerno, Italy.

You’ll also find plenty of gift options for wine-loving friends. In addition to bottles and bundles, you can give gift subscriptions and e-gift cards. Prices start at $13.25 per bottle, and there’s a 3-bottle minimum.

8. Macy’s Wine Shop – Great for Gifting and Bundles

Macy's Wine Shop provides affordable and expertly curated wines. It stands out as a retailer offering premium brands, and its wine club is no exception. Every bottle is chosen by an expert tasting panel, which includes a sommelier and a chef. These experts ensure that each wine lives up to the standards of its parent company, Macy’s Department Store.

You can choose to subscribe to Macy’s Wine Club or place a la carte orders at its online storefront. If you’re a casual wine drinker, or if you aren’t yet ready to commit to a subscription, you can order whenever you’re ready and try the available wines for yourself before making a decision.

When you sign up for Macy’s Wine Club, you get a 12-bottle box of reds, whites, or a mix of both every 12 weeks. (You also get a bonus summer box for parties and a winter box for holiday get-togethers). You start your subscription with a trial box of 6 bottles for just $49.99, which is a great deal.

There are also many curated wine sets and gift options available for special occasions. If you’re looking for presents for your wine-loving friends, Macy’s Wine Shop has Gifts Under $50, Gifts Under $100, and Luxe Gifts that cost between $100 and $250. You can also give them a Macy’s Wine Shop subscription and let them enjoy a regular supply of wine throughout the year.

Prices start at $10.99, and there's a 2-bottle minimum order. Macy’s Wine Shop has a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

9. Monthly Clubs Wine Club – Great for Wine & More

Monthly Clubs Wine, established in 1994, is America’s oldest wine delivery service. Currently operated by Paul Kalemkiarnan Jr, the founder’s son, Monthly Clubs Wine still has many loyal customers who swear by its commitment to quality wines and customer satisfaction.

Wine lovers can choose from 4 distinct wine clubs: The Premier Series, The Bold Reds, The Masters Series, and The Collectors Series. Each club caters to different tastes and preferences, ensuring that whether you prefer classic, bold, or rare wines, there's a club that perfectly matches your palate.

The wines are handpicked by a team of skilled sommeliers. Monthly Clubs Wine’s long history gives it access to many exclusive and high-quality wines that are not typically found in the U.S. market. Our expert reviewer was impressed by the high quality of wines and excellent customer service.

The Premier Series Wine Club offers a monthly delivery of 2 estate-bottled, limited-production wines from boutique wineries in the world's most prestigious regions. If you appreciate the finesse of limited-edition wines from renowned regions, this series is an ideal choice​​.

The Collectors Series Wine Club provides access to rare wines that are ready for further cellaring. This series is perfect if you’re looking to invest in wines that promise to evolve beautifully over time​​.

But Monthly Clubs has more than just wine. You can also join Monthly Clubs for cheese, chocolate, flowers, beer, and cigars. This versatility makes it an excellent choice for those who enjoy pairing their wine with gourmet foods, premium cigars, and fresh flowers​​​​. And when you’re shopping for gifts, Monthly Clubs gives you options for your friends who don’t drink wine.

Monthly Clubs Wine offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, promising “You’ll never pay for a wine you don’t love.” Prices start at $20.98 per bottle, with a 2-bottle minimum order.

10. Winc – Excellent Eco-Friendly Wines

Winc stands out as an environmentally conscious choice for wine enthusiasts. It’s continually expanding its selection of organic, vegan, low-sugar, low-sulfur, and sustainably farmed wines. It also collaborates with vineyards that prioritize suitable wine production practices and donates 1% of its sales to environmental causes.

With Winc, you have the flexibility to select your own bottles or utilize an on-site quiz for personalized recommendations. There are over 50 options available. About 30% of Winc’s wines are domestically sourced, primarily from California. The rest come from international growers. The Wonderful Wine pictured above comes from southeastern France.

Winc’s user-friendly platform lets you use various filters, like varietal and palate preferences. But there’s no option to filter by country. This limitation might be a slight inconvenience for those specifically looking to explore wines from particular regions of the world​​.

Subscribing to Winc is straightforward and costs $59.95 per month. This subscription gives you 60 Winc credits, which you can use towards the purchase of your selected wines. Any unused credits roll over to the following month. You can also buy more credits if you want to order additional wines.

Our reviewer noted that Winc’s most popular wines sell out frequently. If you find a bottle that you particularly enjoy, it's wise to reorder promptly. This shows that Winc’s curators do a good job of picking wines, but it also means you need to be swift in securing your favorites​​.

There is a minimum order of 3 bottles, with prices starting at $12.00 per bottle. Shipping is free on orders over 4 bottles, and orders of 12+ bottles receive a 10% discount. Only Winc subscribers can buy from Winc, as it does not offer a la carte orders.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Wine Clubs

Everybody’s taste in wine is different. If you’re trying to find the best wine clubs for your needs, here are some tips that will help you zoom in on the services that will work best for you. I used these pointers when compiling this list.

• Check prices: You don’t want to spend too much, but you want the best wine you can afford. Firstleaf’s award-winning wines typically come in at between $15 and $30 per bottle. A Firstleaf subscription is a great way to enjoy quality wines without breaking the bank.

• Check shipping costs: Wine bottles are fragile and heavy, so shipping fees can add up. Naked Wines offers free shipping on most of its orders. With a Naked Wines Angel membership, you can order wines whenever you want and never have to worry about unexpected shipping charges.

• Check your wine consumption: You don’t want to accumulate more wine than you can store or enjoy, so order a subscription that fits your needs. Vinesse has a 3-bottle monthly subscription, which is suited to the needs of even light wine drinkers. And if you get overwhelmed, Vinesse also makes it easy to skip shipments.

• Consider your preferences: Check the wine list before subscribing to make sure you find enough wines suitable for your wine palate. If you aren’t sure about your tasting preferences, Bright Cellars offers a solution with its algorithm that selects wines based on your tasting quiz results.

FAQ

What’s the best wine club? 

Firstleaf wins my Best Wine Club seal of approval. While all the wines on this list have something to offer, Firstleaf’s combination of award-winning wines, reasonable prices, and excellent customer service is difficult to beat.

Are wine clubs worth it?

Wine clubs are definitely worth it. Because they skip the middlemen and sell directly to the customer, they can offer you great wines at a significant discount. For example, when you sign up for a Naked Wines Angel membership, you get 40% to 60% off the retail price on all bottles that you purchase.

What’s the best wine club for beginners?

I recommend Bright Cellars to wine novices who like wine but who have little experience with vintages, varietals, or other wine categories. The Bright Cellars algorithm uses your quiz results to send wines suited to your palate. It’s a great way to discover new wines you’ll love.

Best Wine Clubs in 2024 — Final Score