10 Best Wine Clubs That Ship To Montana 2024: Rated

Choosing a wine club that delivers to Montana can be overwhelming. Montanans are blessed with an abundance of options, so choosing the right service can be challenging. After all, not every wine club meets your unique needs for convenience, price, and taste preferences.

To make things easier for you, I reviewed dozens of wine delivery services available in Montana. In doing so, I evaluated them based on variety, price, user experience, customer service, and more. After thorough research, I found the 10 best wine clubs that Montanans should know about.

Based on my findings, Firstleaf stands out as the best choice for Montanans. Known for its affordable prices, focus on wine education, and extensive range of wines from across the globe, you can see why it’s the front-runner on my list. 

If you have other preferences, I have 9 other amazing wine clubs to share with you. By the end of this list, you'll undoubtedly find at least a wine club that aligns perfectly with your needs. So make sure to read till the end!

The Best Wine Clubs That Ship To Montana Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best Overall for Diverse and Affordable Wine Selection

Firstleaf offers an affordably priced personalized wine club. Tailored to meet the diverse preferences of wine drinkers everywhere, this service ensures every bottle you receive is a delight to your palate. The affordability doesn’t compromise the quality, making it an ideal choice for wine enthusiasts seeking diversity and value.

As you drink more wine, Firstleaf’s algorithm adapts the subscription to your taste preferences. But this is only possible if you participate in the wine rating system made available to all Firstleaf members. With this system, every shipment leads to an improvement in the wine selection according to your palate.

With Firstleaf, a vast selection of wines is at your fingertips. From international to domestic and even award-winning varieties, Firstleaf brings the world’s vineyards to Montana. Alongside, you also receive tasting and pairing cards, which add an educational aspect to your wine experience and enhance each glass.

I also like that you can gain insightful information about each wine. Firstleaf offers details on body, acidity, sweetness, fruitiness, and tannin level with every bottle. Additionally, nutritional information, called serving facts, is available on each bottle’s label, allowing you to make informed choices for your health and palate.

Even though the algorithm offers recommendations, you’re in charge of your selection. You have the option to review and swap the recommended labels for other wines you consider best fit your palate. You can learn more about the recommendation system in my colleague’s Firstleaf review.

Like most wine clubs, Firstleaf lets you send out wine gifts. But you can’t send out a selection you consider the giftee would like. Instead, you can send out electronic gift cards of a specific value. This way, the recipient has the freedom to explore and enjoy wines tailored to their liking, making this a personalized wine experience from their point of view.

Firstleaf offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee for every bottle. If you find yourself unhappy with any of the wines you received, Firstleaf will replace it with a bottle of similar value (shipping is not included). This guarantee demonstrates Firstleaf’s commitment to ensuring every Montanan finds joy in each bottle they order.

Firstleaf’s pricing is quite competitive, starting at $7.49 per bottle. The minimum subscription is 6 bottles per month. This pricing structure, paired with the vast and diverse selection, puts Firstleaf as a frontrunner for Montanans seeking quality, variety, and affordability in their wine journey.

2. Naked Wines – Best for Interactions with Independent Winemakers

Naked Wines stands as a beacon of support for independent winemakers. Its main purpose is to foster interactions between highly skilled, small winemakers and customers. The club also offers a vast selection of over 500 wines, with 312 originating from the US, making it a treasure trove for Montanans seeking domestic and diverse wine options.

This service is not your typical online wine club. Rather, it functions as a personalized wine-buying service that you contribute to every month. According to my colleague’s Naked Wines review, this unique approach allows for a more tailored experience, enabling you to explore a wide range of wines from all over the world.

Another unique feature is that Naked Wines operates as a direct-to-consumer winery. By cutting out the middlemen distributors who usually inflate the price of wines in stores, it brings you closer to the winemakers, ensuring a fair price (especially for members).

Your journey starts with an introductory case, after which you have full control. As a member, or “Angel,” as you’ll be called, you have the liberty to purchase wines at your convenience while enjoying member-exclusive pricing (members enjoy up to 60% off market prices).

Naked Wines offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee for every order. If a wine doesn’t meet your expectations, Naked Wines will refund the credits to your account so you can buy a different bottle. This commitment to satisfaction reflects Naked Wines’ dedication to providing a risk-free exploration of unique wines.

Naked Wines also encourages customers to rate its wines. This feature makes you an active contributor to the community of Angels and can lead to connections with other members. But it’s also a great way to tell Naked Wines about your likes and dislikes.

With prices starting at $7.99 per bottle (for members), Naked Wines is reasonably priced. Plus, you have the flexibility to order whenever you want, as there’s no mandatory monthly subscription.

3. Vinesse – Best for Exploring Unique, Boutique Wines

Vinesse features a unique blend of boutique wines at reasonable prices. This is possible due to the strong network of winemakers the company managed to build during its 30-year history in the industry. As such, it can now offer club members the joy of exploring exceptional wines without breaking the bank.

For wine aficionados seeking variety, Vinesse is a treasure trove. Its extensive portfolio embraces reds, whites, sparkling, and rosé wines from all the renowned wine regions worldwide. This eclectic mix invites you on a global wine-tasting adventure, broadening your palate and enriching your appreciation for fine wines.

Vinesse’s curated selection features wines from small, hidden gem producers. Its portfolio only includes wines selected by seasoned tasters who perform rigorous testing. This meticulous approach ensures that each sip you take is a testament to quality and uniqueness.

After scanning the list of wines, I noticed an emphasis on California labels. While this focus brings the best Californian wines to your table, it might limit the geographical diversity for those craving more exotic wines. Still, according to my colleague’s in-depth Vinesse review, you shouldn’t be worried - there are plenty of international wines to try!

Vineese doesn’t ask you to fill in a quiz but will encourage you to rate the wines you buy. This is a great way to make sure future shipments are personalized to your taste and preferences. It’s also a great way to help others discover and appreciate the wines you like.

You can also offer Vinesse wines as a gift. There is a wide selection of wine sets you can choose from, or you can buy and offer a Wine Credit voucher in case you don’t know the recipient’s taste in wines.

Starting at $10.00 per bottle, Vinesse offers a wide range of affordable wines. If you opt for a membership, the minimum order is 6 bottles. You also have access to the satisfaction guaranteed policy, where Vinesse will replace any wine you don’t enjoy.

4. Bright Cellars – Best for Personalized Wine Matching

Bright Cellars makes sure all the wines in your box align with your unique taste profile. To make the experience even more enjoyable, you also get wine cards that enrich your understanding and appreciation of every bottle. This tailored approach transforms your wine journey into a voyage of personalized discovery.

The club uses a somewhat sophisticated quiz to understand your preferences better. Before placing your first order, you’ll answer several questions on your tastes in sweets, teas, and other beverages, as well as your preferred wine-drinking experiences. Bright Cellars will use your answers to recommend wines that fit your tastes.

You can’t directly choose your wines, which is a bit bothersome if you know what you like. However, if you’re new to this world, it’s a great way to get introduced to all sorts of varietals, wine types, and labels from all over the world.

You can, however, swap the wines you don’t like. However, the available alternatives are also algorithm-generated recommendations based on your profile. Still, I find this feature adds a layer of flexibility to the customization process. You can learn more about this in my colleague’s  stellar review of Bright Cellars.

If you’re an adventurous wine drinker, you’ll love the addition of a mystery bottle to your order. Bright Cellars calls it “Sip of the Month,” and it can range from new releases to acclaimed favorites. You won’t know what’s in this bottle until the unboxing, which adds an element of excitement to the experience.

Bright Cellars also offers a wide range of wine bundles for members and non-members. Also, each shipment is thoroughly packed so all your wines reach their destination. The bottles are secured in a sturdy box, which keeps the fragile content safe.

Members enjoy a 15% discount, albeit the prices start at $10.00 per bottle. This puts Bright Cellars on the list of pricier wine clubs, but I like the extra work the club invests in quality and presentation. You can order 4, 6, or 12 bottles, and if you don’t like a wine, Bright Cellars will replace it.

5. Wine Insiders – Best for Value and Curated Selections

Wine Insiders boasts a wide selection of award-winning artisanal wines. The wines on Wine Insiders virtual racks have collectively won over 2,200 awards and come from some of the best vineyards around the world.

The Wine Insiders portfolio includes labels from 12 countries. Therefore, with a simple membership, you can sip wines from the renowned vineyards of California, France, and Italy to the unique flavors of Argentina and Australia. Also, the diverse selection includes red, white, rosé, and sparkling wines.

Exclusivity is a key feature of the Wine Insiders Club. The wines curated for members are unique finds unavailable elsewhere. According to my colleague’s Wine Insiders review, this exclusivity enhances your wine journey, offering a taste of the rare and the extraordinary.

Wine Insiders also runs several celebrity partnerships to create special wine sets. Collaborations with Martha Stewart, Iron Chef Geoffrey Zakarian, and Chef Ludo Lefebvre yield handpicked collections, giving you insights into their preferred wines and the reasons behind their choices. This is a great opportunity to learn from food specialists.

Wine Insiders makes your introductory case a treasure trove of seasonal flavors. In your very first box, you get 12 bottles of reds, whites, or a mix. The first box also comes with 3 extra bottles of premium wine. You also receive tasting notes designed to help you understand each wine’s flavor profile, serving tips, and pairings.

I like that you are in control of the wines that come in your box. While Wine Insiders may make some recommendations based on your order history, you can choose whichever bottle is available in the store. Wine Insiders also offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee – if you don’t like a wine, you’ll get a new bottle with no added costs.

Affordability meets variety in the Wine Insiders pricing structure. Prices start at $8.99 per bottle, and most wines fall within the $10-15 range, offering a balance between value and quality. This makes good quality wine accessible to people with various budgets.

6. The California Wine Club – Award-Winning Small-Batch Wines

The California Wine Club helps artisan wineries share their small-batch wines. Therefore, every wine featured holds a story, and you can be sure it originated in a real, working winery. Furthermore, the club’s specialists visit each winery and meet with the winemakers to gain insights into the crafting of each unique flavor.

The club offers 6 subscription types, or series, catering to a diverse range of needs and budgets. These series are strategically divided into 3 main categories: the Affordable Wine Clubs, the Luxury Wine Clubs, and the More Than Just California series. This way, anyone from casual wine drinkers to connoisseurs can find wines that suit their taste.

The Luxury Wine Clubs category covers 2 series. The Signature Series features California's highest-rated and most coveted artisan wines, while the Aged Cabernet Series is the only wine club that offers Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon aged perfectly for 7 to 12 years.

The California Wine Club also features wines outside of the California region. These are available in the Pacific Northwest Series, which brings wines from small wineries in Washington and Oregon, while the International Series gives you a taste of exquisite wines from around the globe.

Lastly, the Premier Series offers delicious and affordable wines without compromising quality. This series ensures that you can enjoy a variety of wines without breaking the bank. And, according to my colleague’s review of The California Wine Club, this is the most popular series.

If you’d like to share the pleasure of drinking good wine, you can send out wine as a gift. If you don’t know the recipient’s taste in wine, you can also send electronic gift cards with values between $65 and $1000.

Prices for the wines start at a modest $10.99 per bottle, making it an affordable choice for many. Additionally, each membership comes with an optional VIP Touring and Tasting at any of the small family wineries featured by the club.

7. Wine Awesomeness – Great for Affordable, Unique, Global Wines

Wine Awesomeness aims to discover unique global wines worth your palate's time. Its primary mission revolves around hunting down exceptional wine crafted by passionate winemakers from all corners of the globe. The wine it presents isn't just delicious – it comes with stories and experiences that beckon discovery.

Each month introduces you to a new and diversified wine list. Wine Awesomeness ensures you never get bored, offering a curated selection from across 8 different countries. This ever-changing roster promises fresh and intriguing options month after month, so you don’t risk getting bored after the first couple of orders.

Wine Awesomeness is well-connected with authentic wine creators. The club’s diligent team collaborates with winemakers, importers, and vineyards that prioritize genuineness. And, as my colleague highlights in their Wine Awesomeness review, the results are impressive.

The power of choice is always in your hands, which I highly appreciate. You have the option to handpick the wines for your box, but you can also trust Wine Awesomeness’ expertise to curate a selection for you.

Members get a wide range of perks, including exclusive access to the Wine Cellar. This is an online repository that provides digital tasting notes to help you understand your wine better. Additionally, you can delve into recipe pairings that complement your chosen wine and pen down your personal reviews and ratings.

Membership also comes with tangible financial benefits. As a member, you enjoy a flat 20% discount on everything on the Wine Awesomeness list. Moreover, you gain access to unlisted wines and limited small-batch runs. Whether you want 3, 6, or 12 bottles, the choice is yours every month.

Gift-giving is made simple and delightful with Wine Awesomeness. If you're looking to surprise someone, Wine Awesomeness offers a wide range of gifts, from wines you pick to thoughtfully curated boxes tailored for various occasions. And if you're unsure, e-gift cards are a great alternative.

Lastly, affordability is at the forefront of Wine Awesomeness' pricing model. Members can start their wine journey at just $13.25 per bottle. If you don’t want to subscribe, purchasing wines is still an option.

8. Macy’s Wine Shop – Great Deals for Various Taste Preferences

Macy’s Wine Shop boasts a selection from the world’s top wine regions. Alongside classic options like red, white, rosé, and sparkling wines, you also find a diverse array of vegan and organic selections. The club ensures that every wine enthusiast finds something that suits their palate.

Each bottle comes with comprehensive tasting notes. These notes are your guide to exploring the complexities of each wine, providing flavor profiles, serving tips, and pairing ideas. It’s like having a sommelier by your side, helping you get the most out of every sip.

The wine list is spread across 12+ countries and geographic regions. While the majority are sourced from renowned wine-producing countries like France, the US, Spain, and Italy, Macy’s Wine Shop also introduces you to gems from Chile, Portugal, Argentina, and other prestigious regions.

Macy’s Wine Shop also features wine collections to simplify your wine-choosing process. Thoughtfully designed collections like Sommelier’s Choice and Customer Favorites are ideal when you’re in need of inspiration. These collections provide a guiding hand, showcasing wines that have been vetted and vouched for by experts and fellow customers.

Another special collection, vetted by Martha Stewart herself, stands as a testament to quality. The collection offers an array of options that reflect the icon’s discerning palate and passion for wine. For more on Macy’s Wine Shop collections, check our comprehensive review.

The collection I personally found extremely interesting was the Rated Under $20. If you, like me, are watching your budget, this collection is a treasure trove. It proves that you don’t need to break the bank to enjoy a good bottle of wine.

Macy’s Wine Shop curates Wine Sets ideal for gifting and special occasions. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, hosting a dinner, or looking for the perfect gift, these sets have been assembled with a variety of occasions in mind.

Membership pricing starts at a competitive $10.99 per bottle. As a member, every 12 weeks, you have the opportunity to explore 6 expertly-curated wines.

9. Monthly Clubs Wine – Best for Customizable Subscription Options

Since 1994, Monthly Clubs Wine has been a gateway to rare, extraordinary wines. Being active for so long, it has cultivated relationships and knowledge that translate into exceptional offerings. Therefore, the club can offer unique and hard-to-find gems that truly elevate your wine experience.

The wine list includes a range of estate bottled wines and rare finds. Expect international variety in every shipment, complemented by a detailed profiling of each wine and winery. This approach ensures that each bottle you receive has a story and character, adding depth to your tasting experience. Learn more about the club’s varied wine list from our in-depth review.

This is possible due to the team’s unparalleled dedication to quality. The wine specialists behind the Monthly Clubs Wine travels to top wine-producing regions, inspecting vineyards and meeting with winemakers. It’s a rigorous process of tasting and selecting, ensuring that only the finest wines make it to your monthly box.

Since not all wine drinkers are the same, there are 4 distinct wine club memberships. The Premier Series is the most sought-after membership. This series is where you will find premium wines that strike a balance between exceptional quality and value. It’s a well-rounded option for those looking to explore a variety of affordable wines without compromising on value.

The Bold Reds Series is a haven for red wine enthusiasts. If you have a penchant for robust red wines with deep fruit flavors, pronounced ripe tannins, superb structure, and well-integrated oak tones, this series will meet your expectations.

The Collectors Series offers exclusivity with its rare finds. This series is tailored for those who seek extremely limited production offerings. While it comes with a higher price tag, the uniqueness and rarity of the wines justify the investment.

Monthly Clubs Wine’s pricing is as diverse as the wine selection. It starts at $20.98 per bottle for The Premier Series and can go up to around $40 per bottle for The Collectors Series. This range accommodates different budgets while ensuring a premium experience.

10. Plonk Wine Club – Your Source of Organic and Biodynamic Wines

Plonk Wine Club is renowned for offering hidden gem, artisan wines. Specializing in organic and biodynamic varieties, Plonk sources wines from small-scale farmers across more than 20 domestic and international regions. This focus on sustainability and quality means you’re introduced to hidden gems that are not just unique but also crafted with care for the environment.

The club introduces you to native grapes from lesser-known appellations. These grapes are nurtured using organic and biodynamic methods, ensuring that no pesticides or commercial additives tarnish the natural character of the wine. The result is a pure, authentic taste experience, bringing you closer to the essence of the grape and the terroir.

Plonk’s offer features a wide range of options, such as organic grown or certified organic. There are also versions like low alcohol, no added sugar, or low sulfites. In short, every wine in your shipment represents a step away from the commercial and a step closer to nature.

I like that you also have options when it comes to selecting your bottles. You can let Plonk act as your personal wine concierge and have the team curate wine selections for you, or you can build your own case. Each wine comes with detailed tasting notes and recipe pairings, so you can be as adventurous as you’d like with your selection.

Plonk features 3 distinct memberships (or wine clubs) that cater to varied preferences. Find out all the details in our comprehensive review. Whether you’re a fan of red, white, or enjoy a mix of both (this membership also includes rosé and bubbly varieties), there’s something for you.

You can be quite flexible when it comes to your own case size. Plonk lets you choose 4, 6, or 12 bottles per shipment. This flexibility is great in attracting both casual sippers and devoted enthusiasts. There’s also the option to give a club subscription as a gift.

Prices start at $9.50 per bottle, which is quite steep. However, it’s worth considering that you have access to a wide range of organic and biodynamic wines. These versions are usually a bit more expensive because of the more sensitive and time-consuming production methods.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Wine Clubs That Ship To Montana

Here are some of the criteria I followed when putting together the list of the best wine clubs that ship to Montana:

• Check if Montana is on the delivery map: This is crucial as it ensures the service is available in your area. For example, Firstleaf has a comprehensive delivery map that includes Montana, so you won't face any shipping issues.

• Look at the wine list size and variety: A diverse selection guarantees you'll always have something new to try. Naked Wines, for instance, offers a vast array of wines, allowing you to explore different flavors and types.

• Consider the wine regions: This aspect helps you explore wines from different areas and terroirs. A service like Vinesse offers a great example of unique boutique wines from various regions, giving you the opportunity to taste diversity in your glass.

• Consider the overall subscription price: Balancing quality and cost is key to enjoying your wine subscription. In this case, Wine Insiders is notable for offering a variety of high-quality wines at competitive prices.

FAQ

How much does it cost to join a wine club?

Costs can vary significantly. Some wine clubs, like Firstleaf, have a monthly subscription that varies depending on the number of bottles you want in each shipment. Moreover, Firstleaf’s first order comes with some significant discounts, so it’s worth giving it a try.

Do wine clubs offer any guarantees or return policies?

Many wine clubs offer satisfaction guarantees. This means that they will replace or refund bottles that don’t meet your expectations. Naked Wines, for instance, will add credits to your account for any wine you don’t like. You don’t have to return the bottle – just tell customer support about your problems with the wine.

Are wine clubs a good way to learn about wine?

Absolutely, joining a wine club can be an excellent way to learn about wines! Wine Insiders is a great example of a club with great educational resources. With their guides and wine cards, you learn about types of wines, wine regions, and food pairings.

Best Wine Clubs That Ship To Montana in 2024 — Final Score