10 Best Wine Delivery Brooklyn 2024: Expert Rankings

Navigating the best wine delivery Brooklyn offers that also matches your palate can be daunting, given the borough’s famous wine scene. With an abundance of options, identifying those that deliver wines you’re guaranteed to love requires some guidance. I’ll shed some light on my favorite options that I think you’ll like.

I’ve meticulously evaluated services to cater to diverse tastes and budgets. Whether your palate favors bold reds for chilly winters, invigorating whites for hot summers, effervescent sparkling, or rich dessert wines, there’s a curated option for everyone. Join me today to find the cream of the crop options.

Firstleaf earns my number 1 recommendation. The company delivers a personalized wine experience through a detailed 13-step quiz. This process refines your options, ensuring a balance of quality and value. For those embarking on a quest for the best bottle, Firstleaf is a great option with its selection of over 300 global wines.

The 10 Best Wine Delivery Brooklyn Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best Global Selection of 300+ Wines

Firstleaf offers over 300 wines from around the world, including Greece, Italy, and Argentina. Living in Brooklyn, you likely appreciate variety. Firstleaf’s extensive collection brings a world of flavors to your doorstep, with wines from North America, South America, Europe, South Africa, and other regions offering unique options.

Some wines on offer include red like cabernet sauvignon, white like chardonnay, rosé, and sparkling options. There are also specialty types like keto- and eco-friendly along with lower alcohol options. Learn more about all these options in my colleague’s detailed review.

You can choose from reds, whites, sparkling, and rosé wines. In a place like Brooklyn with a diverse food scene, having a variety of wines to complement different cuisines is a practical advantage. There’s a suitable bottle for every meal and occasion.

Delivery is available every 1 to 3 months. Given the busy lifestyle in Brooklyn, this flexible schedule ensures a steady supply of wines without the need for constant reordering. It’s a convenient option whether you’re an occasional drinker or a wine enthusiast.

There’s a 13-question quiz to pinpoint your preferences. Brooklyn hosts a mix of tastes, and Firstleaf uses this quiz to understand what you like. This way, every bottle you receive is more likely to suit your palate, enhancing your overall experience.

The team evaluates 10,000 wines to curate the selection. Knowing that a dedicated team has scrutinized the selection offers reassurance about the quality of the wines you receive. It aligns with the high standards and varied options that Brooklyn residents are accustomed to.

Firstleaf gives a full refund for any bottle you don’t like. This policy reflects the value Brooklynites place on quality and accountability. It allows you to explore different wines confidently, with the assurance of a refund if a bottle isn’t to your liking.

Gifts are also available. For instance, you can send out a gift card, wine bundles, or single wine bottles to your favorite people. You could choose from the 3 Bottle Mixed Bundle, 90+ Point Picks Red bundle, or any red, white, sparkling, or rosé wine of your choice.

Pricing starts at $7.49. The varied budget ranges in Brooklyn are considered in Firstleaf’s pricing model, making a diverse selection of wines accessible to many. It’s a straightforward and affordable way for you to enjoy different wines at home.

2. Naked Wines – Best Small Batch Wines

With Naked Wines, selecting your own wines is easy. This feature suits the diverse tastes of Brooklyn residents, allowing you to pick wines that best align with your preferences. Whether hosting an intimate gathering in Dumbo or a dinner in Park Slope, having the ability to choose ensures that the wine is always to your liking.

A variety of wine types are available, including reds, whites, and more. The diverse culinary landscape of Brooklyn calls for a versatile wine selection. Whether you’re pairing wine with artisanal cheeses in Williamsburg or dessert in Bay Ridge, Naked Wines has an option that will elevate your dining experience.

"Angel" members enjoy 20 to 30% off on any wine. In a borough where savvy shopping is valued, these discounts are significant. They ensure that you can savor quality wines without straining your budget, making it an appealing option for those looking to balance cost and quality. Learn more in my colleague’s full review.

Membership is $40 a month, and you can cancel anytime for free. The flexibility of Naked Wines’ membership aligns well with the dynamic lifestyle of Brooklynites. It provides the freedom to explore a variety of wines with the assurance that you can opt-out whenever it suits you.

Delivery intervals are flexible, ranging from 1 to 3 months. This delivery schedule is designed to fit into the bustling lives of Brooklyn residents. Whether you enjoy wine frequently or occasionally, having it delivered at suitable intervals is convenient and ensures you’re never without a bottle when you need it.

Famous winemakers, including Matt Parish and Stefano di Blasi, craft the wines. Knowing that renowned winemakers are behind the bottle adds to the confidence of enjoying a quality product. Some examples include the Brothers Miller Organic Paso Robles Cabernet Sauvignon 2021 (pictured) and the Matt Parish Napa Valley Tino 2020.

Naked Wines credits you for any bottle you don’t like. This policy supports the Brooklyn ethos of value for money. It allows you to explore the variety with assurance, knowing that if a selection doesn’t meet your expectation, it’s not a loss.

Pricing for Naked Wines starts at $7.99, with free shipping on orders over $200. In Brooklyn, where residents have varied budgets, this pricing structure makes quality small-batch wines accessible to a broader audience. It’s an affordable way to explore and enjoy wines crafted by renowned winemakers.

3. Vinesse – Best Overall Variety

Vinesse is known for bringing rare wines from obscure vineyards straight to your table. For those living in Brooklyn, this offers a chance to taste unique flavors that are not commonly available in local wine stores. 

The distinctiveness of its offerings has garnered attention from recognized magazines like Self and Conde Nast Traveler. I like that this adds a layer of credibility for discerning Brooklyn wine drinkers. Find out more in our full Vinesse review.

Joining Vinesse is uncomplicated. Simply select the type of wine you prefer, specify whether it’s a gift, and fill in your shipping and billing information. Before you know it, you’ll be part of an exclusive community that appreciates extraordinary wines from diverse regions of the world.

With several distinctive wine clubs, Vinesse accommodates a spectrum of wine tastes. If your palate leans towards the lighter, sweeter side, the Light & Sweet club might be your match. If you’re intrigued by international varieties, the World of Wine club is a fitting choice. And if you have a preference for domestic flavors, the American Cellars club could be your haven.

Membership with Vinesse means an abundance of choices. You have the liberty to choose whether you’re inclined towards reds, dedicated to whites, or enjoy a balanced blend of both. The diverse options cater to the eclectic preferences of Brooklyn residents, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

Your experience begins with an introductory pack of 8 wines for $49.99. This allows you to explore Vinesse’s carefully selected range before settling into regular deliveries every 5 to 7 weeks. It’s a way for Brooklynites to sample and discover what Vinesse has to offer.

Regarding delivery, every bottle from Vinesse is securely packaged. You can decide whether to have it delivered to your home or office in Brooklyn. If, for any reason, a delivery doesn’t reach you, there’s the option to collect it from a nearby FedEx station.

The cost of each delivery is determined by the club you’re part of. Pricing typically commences at $10.00 for each set. The transparency in pricing is a breath of fresh air, with no concealed membership fees, ensuring you only spend on the wine you receive. For Brooklyn dwellers mindful of value, this straightforward approach to pricing is appealing.

4. Bright Cellars – Best Wine Bundles

Brooklyn dwellers, Bright Cellars fine-tunes wine options through a personalized quiz. Living in this borough, you find diverse tastes and preferences, making the personalized approach a pleasant fit for you. Reading a review from a colleague will reveal more insights on how the quiz customizes your wine choices.

This company delivers distinctive wines from undiscovered vineyards. As someone residing in Brooklyn, you have an appreciation for uniqueness and variety. You’ll appreciate the range of flavors that includes classic wines as well as unconventional varietals. 

There’s a suitable wine available for every Brooklynite occasion. Whether attending a large celebration in Prospect Park or enjoying a quiet evening on your brownstone’s porch, you’ll discover wines that suit your preference. From sweet and fruity to deep and rich, there’s something here for everyone.

Bright Cellars excels in providing detailed information about each wine. For example, take the White Wine Variety Bundle (pictured). Each bottle (like the Meet Cute Chardonnay (2021) from Lodi, CA) comes with detailed info about the region, optimal serving temperature, ABV, flavor profile, and what foods it pairs well with.

However, for those who prefer handpicking every bottle, it might not be the ideal choice. Brooklyn’s eclectic nature means some might favor selecting each wine, making an alternative like Wine Awesomeness a potential better fit.

Membership offers benefits like earning points and friend referral bonuses. To start, Brooklynites can take the Bright Cellars quiz to influence the wine selections towards their liking.

After completing the quiz, the checkout process is your next step. The wine is sent in a sturdy cardboard box, with each bottle securely separated, ensuring it reaches Brooklyn in prime condition. Each package includes informative cards about the wines.

New wine sets are regularly introduced to keep the selection interesting. A notable example is the Pleasure Principle Old Vine Zinfandel Bundle, which features 4 2019 California Zinfandels. This specific variety has an ABV of 14.7%, providing quite a kick for Brooklyn wine enthusiasts.

Shipping to Brooklyn typically takes 2 to 4 business days. Tracking details are shared – but be mindful that a person at least 21 years old with a valid ID is required to sign for the delivery. Pricing starts at $10.00 per bottle.

5. Wine Insiders – Best Affordable Wine Delivery

Wine Insiders shines by presenting wines rich in flavor yet easy on the wallet. For the Brooklyn dwellers with a taste for fine wine, the pricing is hard to overlook. Martha Stewart and Geoffrey Zakarian are among the public figures who have contributed to curating the wine selections. 

Brooklynites will discover a vast array of wine types. From robust reds to crisp whites, bubbly sparklings to elegant rosés, and even luscious dessert wines, the selection is expansive. Originating from diverse regions such as Argentina, Austria, Chile, and the United States, each bottle tells a unique story, appealing to the culturally rich residents of Brooklyn.

It showcases an extensive catalog of over 100 bottles. On occasion, a wine crafted by a distinguished winemaker graces the collection. While it doesn’t always feature the most famous labels, the assortment available, ranging from organic and vegan to canned wines and cocktails, is notably diverse, resonating with the varied preferences of Brooklyn locals.

Numerous available wines hold ratings above 90 and bear price tags below $20. However, for those on the hunt for exclusive or vintage wines, it might not be the first choice. Notably, wines like the 2020 Marquis de Bacalon Bordeaux Blanc have garnered impeccable 5-star reviews from various critics. Learn more about its selection in my full review.

Detailed information about each wine is readily available on the site. It classifies the wines into 6 sets based on price and volume, with some sets featuring the larger Magnum bottles. For an informed Brooklyn wine enthusiast, this provides an easy way to find a bottle that suits your taste and budget.

A subscription service is also at your disposal for those who fancy regular wine deliveries. Every quarter, you receive 12 bottles, with the option to choose between reds, whites, or a mix of both. The first shipment includes 3 additional bottles. Some orders may come with a wine-related gift, adding a touch of excitement for Brooklyn subscribers.

Pricing begins at $8.99, with the upper limit for a regular bottle around $25. Magnum wine sets are also available. Prices for these fluctuate between $35 for a single bottle to approximately $47 each for a case of six. 

6. The California Wine Club – Best California Wines

The California Wine Club first began by highlighting Golden State wines. Originating with a concentration on California's finest, it soon branched out, embracing selections from the Pacific Northwest and diverse international regions, offering Brooklyn residents a global wine tasting journey.

You support small, family-run wineries when joining. The selection available is vast and varied, aiming to satisfy every palate, with a focus on quality and authenticity. Check out my colleague’s review for a deeper understanding.

Red wine lovers in Brooklyn will find a plethora of choices. It features a wide spectrum of robust reds, from Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot to Pinot Noir and Zinfandel, each bottle promising an authentic and rich taste experience.

White wine enthusiasts aren’t left out, with a diverse selection available. Options include popular varieties such as Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio, and Riesling, ensuring that every bottle delivered to Brooklyn is of the highest quality.

Membership offers access to a range of specialized monthly clubs. Catering to the diverse tastes of Brooklynites, the Signature Series club is ideal for those seeking unique, limited-edition wines, while the Premier Series club provides a comprehensive overview of California's award-winning selections.

A special collection of aged Cabernet Sauvignon is available for enthusiasts. The Aged Cabernet Series club is a treasure for those who appreciate wines that have matured gracefully over 8 to 12 years, providing a unique offering for Brooklyn residents with discerning tastes.

International selections promise a global wine-tasting experience. For those in Brooklyn with a love for world flavors, the International Selections Club offers a curated exploration of wines from various countries, enhancing the diversity of your wine collection.

The Pacific Northwest Series Club showcases distinct, cool-climate wines. Focusing on selections from Oregon and Washington State, this club introduces wines with different flavor profiles, adding variety to the wine scene in Brooklyn.

Membership is more than receiving fine wines; it’s a holistic experience. Brooklyn residents receive comprehensive tasting notes, an exclusive magazine, attractive discounts, and the option to personalize their wine deliveries, making every shipment feel like a bespoke wine journey.

Pricing is transparent, starting at $10.99 per bottle. Numerous gifting options cater to the diverse needs of Brooklyn, including Wine Club Gifts, Curated Wine Gift Sets, Corporate Wine Gifts, and Digital Gift Certificates for those embracing modernity.

7. Wine Awesomeness – Best Curated Wine Sets

Wine Awesomeness presents a monthly gateway to diverse wine experiences. Tailored to the eclectic taste of Brooklyn dwellers, it provides a curated selection of unique, lesser-known wines, ensuring each sip is a departure from the ordinary. If you’re interested in learning more about what you can expect, check out my colleague’s comprehensive review.

It also provides a digital magazine titled "The Back Label". This publication is a rich source of knowledge, invaluable to both the wine novice and the seasoned connoisseur residing in Brooklyn, aiming to deepen their understanding of wines.

Wine Awesomeness offers 2 subscription options. Brooklynites can opt for a package of 3 bottles at $49, or a more generous 6 bottles for $79, with the added advantage of inclusive shipping.

Monthly themes significantly influence the wine selections. It has showcased a variety of themes, ranging from French varietals to rosés suitable for Brooklyn gatherings, and even options that pair well with barbecues. Regularly checking the website is advisable, as themes are subject to frequent change.

The wine assortment provided is remarkably diverse. Residents of Brooklyn can explore a spectrum ranging from reds and whites to sparkling wines, rosés, and organic alternatives. It also features trendy canned wine and exclusive collections from online sensations like Opopop, Shannon St. Clair, Nail Betch, and Emily Post, adding a distinctive touch.

Purchasing individual bottles is an available option. If subscriptions do not align with your preferences, this flexibility allows you to venture beyond the monthly delivery, a feature not universally provided by competitors.

One particular feature I found quite interesting is the "mystery" wine option. For a predetermined price, you receive a bottle of undisclosed type, introducing an element of surprise and breaking the monotony of conventional wine buying experiences.

A comprehensive rating system evaluates every bottle. With a maximum score of 5, these ratings, derived from both staff and fellow wine enthusiasts, guide you towards community-approved selections.

Gifting is made convenient with themed gift boxes. Crafted with various occasions in mind, these boxes provide an assortment of wines, making gift-giving in Brooklyn both simple and considerate. At Wine Awesomeness, prices start at $13.25 per bottle.

8. Macy’s Wine Shop – Best 6-Bottle Wine Sets

Macy's Wine Shop unveils a plethora of wine choices every month. Through club membership, a handpicked assortment of 6 international wines lands at your Brooklyn doorstep every 3 months.

Commit to the club for an entire 365 days, and relish in 2 extra free bottles. One bottle graces your winter, and another complements the summer, proving ideal for the varying climates of Brooklyn.

Macy’s Wine Shop allows Brooklyn dwellers to immerse themselves in a vast array of wines. In terms of red wines, you can experience everything from the silky tones of Cabernet Franc and Montepulciano to the distinctive tastes of Petite Sirah and Sangiovese. Paired with a meal or enjoyed solo, disappointment seems unlikely.

For those inclined toward white wines, Macy's Wine Shop offers an extensive range. You can relish the smooth nuances of Chardonnay, the sharpness of Muscadet, and even travel from the sunny shores of Portugal to the dramatic terrains of Chile with each sip, all while residing in Brooklyn.

Specialty collections are available for those seeking something unique. The Sommelier’s Choice presents options that will satisfy any wine connoisseur, and a variety of vegan and organic wines are accessible for the environmentally conscious Brooklyn resident. More information about it is available in a comprehensive review by a colleague.

Membership at Macy's Wine Shop is about more than just beverages. It’s an enriching experience, offering the chance to sample limited-edition vintages and deepen your understanding. With detailed tasting notes accompanying each bottle, you’re sure to find out everything there is to know before making your purchase.

Gift-giving is simplified with varied options available. Brooklynites can choose from sets of 3, 6, or 12 bottles, ranging from Luxe Gifts to budget-conscious selections, and even specialized wedding sets, ensuring there’s a suitable option for every occasion.

Exploration is encouraged with a constantly evolving selection. You have the liberty to delve into Essential Wines, keep it relaxed with Easy-Drinking Reds, or celebrate with Award Winners, raising a figurative glass, provided you’re 21 or over.

9. Monthly Clubs – Best Gourmet Club

Each month, Monthly Clubs offers a unique wine adventure without leaving Brooklyn. It presents a diverse range of wine styles, including iconic reds, refreshing whites, and occasional sparkling selections, ensuring there's something for every Brooklyn wine enthusiast.

The wine selection, while not exhaustive, is far from restrictive. Brooklynites have the opportunity to discover a variety of wines, from Sangiovese, Pinot Bianco, and Riesling to bolder varieties like Merlot, adaptable Pinot Noir, and hearty Shiraz.

The wines are meticulously chosen by expert sommeliers. Exquisite picks such as S. Sebastião Vinho Regional Lisboa Syrah/Touriga Nacional Reserva 2020 and Herdade Aldeia de Cima Serra do Mendro Alentejo Reserva Tinto 2019 are among the top-tier offerings.

Monthly Clubs offers 4 distinct subscription options. Each month, you receive 2 carefully selected bottles from your preferred subscription, featuring rare reds or whites from popular vineyards. Learn more about all the different clubs and subscriptions in our full review.

Every bottle is accompanied by an informative card detailing its characteristics. This card provides insights into the origin, flavor profile, and ideal food pairings of the wine, making each bottle feel like a personalized selection from a private sommelier.

Being a member is an educational journey, not just a way to fulfill wine desires. With each bottle, you explore the diverse world of wine, learning about the unique flavors each region brings to the table, all from the comfort of your Brooklyn home.

Membership duration is flexible according to your preferences. Whether you opt for a few months or a full year, you control the length of your membership. Additionally, you have the freedom to tailor your wine selections based on your taste, whether you favor reds or have a penchant for wines from specific regions.

Prices at Monthly Clubs start at $20.98 per bottle. However, I found that most bottles fall somewhere between $20 and $50.

10. Wine Library – Best Variety of Wine and Other Liquor

Venturing into Wine Library is akin to stepping into Brooklyn's grand liquor marketplace. It grants you the freedom to sift through an extensive assortment of wines, devoid of any mandatory monthly commitments. Whether your preference leans towards robust reds, invigorating whites, or effervescent options, a plethora of choices await your exploration.

Navigating through its organized sections feels refreshingly uncomplicated. You’ll find categories such as Top wines under $30 or Wines with a 90+ rating, assuring you access to premium wines without straining your budget. And for those instances where you fancy a lavish treat, a spectrum of high-end selections is available.

Wine Library embodies a world of flavors, mirroring Brooklyn’s multicultural vibe. Featuring wines from diverse regions including Spain, the U.S., Italy, France, and Argentina, it satisfies the eclectic tastes of Brooklynites. If a French Pinot Noir or an Italian Merlot is what you crave, you’re sure to find a bottle you’ll love here.

Education is intertwined with your experience at Wine Library. Each bottle features extensive details including flavor nuances and distinctive characteristics. It’s the next best thing to actually tasting the bottle before buying it.

Wine Library TV stands as your digital wine sanctuary. It offers a ton of helpful video content – reviews, tastings, and dialogues, all sculpted to deepen your understanding of the wines on offer. 

Subscribing to the email list unlocks a trove of exclusive benefits. Curated wine picks, diverse beverage suggestions, and exceptional deals are delivered straight to your inbox, elevating it above the multitude of wine subscription lists I’ve experienced.

Furthermore, Wine Library evolves into a treasure trove for wine aficionados in Brooklyn. In search of elegant wine glasses, practical bottle openers, or innovative tools to preserve your wine’s freshness? You’re bound to unearth them on the Wine Library’s digital aisles.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Wine Delivery to Brooklyn

Here’s what I took into consideration when choosing wine deliveries in Brooklyn. I recommend that you keep these points in mind when making your choice:

• Variety and selection: A service offering diverse choices in wine types, regions, and vintages will cater to both enthusiasts and casual drinkers, ensuring everyone finds their favorite bottle. Firstleaf has a great selection to choose from.

• Speed and reliability: Prompt and dependable deliveries are crucial for last-minute orders and special occasions. Check reviews and ratings to ensure previous customers have had positive experiences with the delivery timeliness and the condition of the wine upon arrival. All the services on my list have great customer reviews.

• Pricing and subscription options: Some services might offer competitive prices, bulk purchase discounts, or customizable subscription options that allow you to explore different wines regularly, providing both value and convenience. You can compare the prices of my top 10 services here.

• Customer service: Accessible and responsive customer support ensures that any queries or issues with your order are resolved promptly, contributing to a seamless and enjoyable wine-buying experience.

FAQ

Can I get wine delivered to NY?

Absolutely. Brooklyn residents can delight in Firstleaf’s extensive selection of 300 global wines. This selection ensures there’s something for every palate. With such a variety, finding a wine that suits your taste is a breeze.

What’s the best wine delivery service in Brooklyn with free shipping?

Naked Wines is a standout choice, offering free shipping on orders of 6 bottles or more. This deal makes it an attractive option for wine enthusiasts in Brooklyn looking to explore a diverse array of quality wines without the extra cost.

Does shipping affect wine?

Yes and no. Shipping can impact wine, but reputable services like Vinesse prioritize safe and undisturbed delivery. Vinesse, another of my top recommendations, offers up an impressive selection of wines and is committed to ensuring that every bottle reaches you in impeccable condition.

Best Wine Delivery Brooklyn in 2024 — Final Score