7 Best Wine Delivery to New Jersey 2023: Only the Finest

There are many wine delivery services that ship to New Jersey, with selections to suit every palate and every level of wine expertise. But amidst all those choices, finding a service that’s right for you can be a real challenge.

To save you time, I've researched and reviewed numerous wine delivery services. For my analysis, I considered the range of wines, price points, delivery reliability, and customer reviews. I’ve also verified that every service on this list delivers to New Jersey addresses. And after careful research, I've shortlisted the 7 top wine delivery options for New Jersey residents.

Firstleaf stands out as the top recommendation for New Jersey wine delivery. It boasts an impressive range of both domestic and international wines, all priced under $30 a bottle. But all the wine services on my list guarantee quality wines at a fair price, delivered straight to your New Jersey home.

The Best Wine Delivery to New Jersey Reviewed

1. Firstleaf – Best Wine Delivery to New Jersey in 2023

Firstleaf uses a sophisticated algorithm to craft a wine profile tailored to your preferences. Over time, the wines delivered to your New Jersey doorstep become more in tune with your personal taste. This personal touch ensures that each bottle you receive aligns with your palate.

Many Firstleaf wines have won awards at major competitions, guaranteeing that you're getting a taste of some of the best wines available. For New Jersey residents who value quality, knowing that the wine you're sipping has been recognized on the global stage can be quite satisfying.

Your Firstleaf subscription lets you explore wines from international vineyards. Firstleaf, sources wines from globally renowned regions, such as South Africa, France, and Italy, as well as lesser-known wine locations like Argentina and Chile. There’s also a solid selection of domestic wines from the West Coast and other American winegrowing regions. 

The “Wine Concierges'' of Firstleaf provide complimentary consultations, helping you to discover wines that resonate with your palate. Especially if you're new to wines or looking to expand your horizons, this personal touch is a great way to broaden your wine experience. Our expert reviewer spoke very highly of Firstleaf’s customer service.

Firstleaf commits to an eco-friendly approach by ensuring its entire shipping process is carbon-neutral. Every time you order, you can feel good knowing you're not only enjoying great wine but also supporting a sustainable practice. 

You can schedule the shipping date for your Firstleaf box, and it will be delivered by UPS Ground or FedEx Ground within 2-5 days. You can also have your package delivered to a UPS or FedEx store where it can be picked up at your convenience. 

While you save up to 30% with a Firstleaf subscription, a la carte orders are available. Firstleaf offers competitive pricing, with bottles starting at $7.49 each. This ensures that New Jersey residents can enjoy quality wines without breaking the bank, making every sip worthwhile. However, bear in mind that there is a 6-bottle minimum for every order. 

2. Vinesse – Best Selection of Boutique Wines

Vinesse specializes in sourcing unique wines from smaller, less-known vineyards. If you're in New Jersey and are looking for something other than the typical, mass-produced labels, Vinesse brings carefully selected wines from boutique vineyards right to your doorstep, broadening your wine horizons without requiring a trip to the vineyard yourself.

You can choose from a range of 14 different wine clubs to suit varying tastes. No matter your preference — whether it’s red, white, sparkling, or a diverse mix—there’s likely a club just for you. Each club offers a unique focus, from regional specialties to specific grape varieties.

Vinesse offers both 1-time wine boxes and ongoing memberships. You have the flexibility to either dip your toes in with a 1-time box of specially curated wines or dive into a full-fledged membership for regular deliveries. 

The Grab Bag Wine Club features wines at clearance prices, but high-end bottles are also available. You can get seasonal wines for as low as $10 to $16 a bottle, making it a great choice if you're on a budget. And if you're looking for something more luxurious, Vinesse also offers bottles that hit the $100 mark, so all wine price points are covered.

Navigating through Vinesse's extensive wine options is surprisingly easy. While the broad range of choices may seem overwhelming at first, our reviewer found the website user-friendly and intuitive. The streamlined design and helpful filters make finding the right wine a straightforward process.

Vinesse is a fantastic option for both novice and seasoned wine enthusiasts. Its diverse range appeals to both the curious beginner who wishes to explore and the seasoned aficionado seeking rare finds. The selection includes educational material and tasting notes to further enrich your wine journey.

You have the option to customize bottle count, wine type, and delivery frequency.  Whether it’s a 1-time event or a recurring need, you can set the terms of your wine deliveries to fit your lifestyle. Prices for Vinesse's wines start at $10.00, and there’s no minimum order requirement. 

3. Bright Cellars – Best Option for Wine Novices

Bright Cellars has a precise wine-sorting algorithm from MIT engineers. The algorithm takes your tastes and preferences into account when making recommendations. This makes it a great choice for New Jersey wine novices who want to expand their wine knowledge.

The algorithm relies on the expertise of a certified sommelier and a team of wine experts. This team meticulously provides the algorithm with data on the body, sweetness, bitterness, astringency, and other crucial wine characteristics. This results in curated selections tailored to your palate. Our expert reviewer spoke highly of Bright Cellars customer service and wine curation. 

Bright Cellars customer service staff undergo training from the Wine & Spirit Education Trust. This organization is known for certifying sommeliers, thereby ensuring you'll receive knowledgeable support if you run into any issues or have questions about your delivery.

Membership comes with perks through the Bright Cellars reward program. As a member, you can earn points that can be redeemed for bonus bottles, upgrades, and more. 

Many of the wines you'll receive are sourced from Bright Cellars' own winery. Others are acquired from vendors who focus on smaller, non-retail vineyards. This offers a chance to taste unique wines that you may not find in your local New Jersey liquor stores. And in addition to wine, Bright Cellars also offers premade bottled margaritas.

You should know that individual bottle selection isn't available; you must opt for a wine bundle. While this provides you with less flexibility than you get with some other services, Bright Cellars has a good track record for sending customers wines they love. 

Prices start at $10.00 per bottle, with a 4-bottle subscription costing $80 per month, or $20 per bottle. While Bright Cellars is a bit more expensive than some of the other services on our list, many wine lovers find that its top-notch customer service and great selection of quality wines are worth the added expense.  

4. Wine Insiders – Best Choice of Celebrity Recommendations

Wine Insiders offers a broad array of sub-$20 wines from around the world. If you want to explore international wines without breaking the bank, you’ll find many options that allow you to expand your palate without emptying your wallet. Our reviewer felt that Wine Insiders punched well above its price points when it came to wine quality. 

Every wine comes with comprehensive details about its background and tasting notes. You get insightful information on the varietals, producers, and regions featured. You also get flavor profiles, serving suggestions, and pairing recommendations. Selections come from an expansive list of countries ranging from classic wine regions like Spain and Portugal to less familiar wine locales like Morocco and Mexico.

The Wine Insiders curatorial team brings over 50 years of experience to the table. IT rigorously evaluates thousands of wines each year, with only 3% making the cut. Wine Insiders also offers celebrity curations by famous wine experts like Martha Stewart, uber-hostess and spokesperson for the meal delivery service Marley Spoon. 

Wine Insiders also offers a good selection of specialty wine options. Whether you're looking for organic, vegan, or even canned wine options, this service has got you covered. New Jersey residents with particular dietary needs or lifestyle preferences can easily find wines that suit them. Our expert reviewer was very impressed with the Wine Insiders selection. 

Customers have a range of box options for their bimonthly deliveries. Choose from white, red, or mixed boxes containing 3, 4, 6, or 12 bottles. The flexibility in box size and wine type accommodates the unique needs and tastes of every wine lover in New Jersey.

Prices start at $8.99 per bottle, typically falling between $10 and $30 per bottle. While specific pricing varies, the affordability factor remains consistent. You get to enjoy a premium wine experience in New Jersey without the premium price tag.

5. Wine Awesomeness – Best for New Wine Surprises Every Month

Wine Awesomeness offers curated selections from its team of experts. Its team of experienced sommeliers and wine experts handpick bottles from independent wineries across the globe, ensuring that you receive a unique and high-quality selection each month.

Its curated boxes help you expand your wine horizons. By delivering different varietals that you might not have otherwise considered, Wine Awesomeness ensures that each subscription box is an opportunity for discovery. You have the choice to pick your wines or let Wine Awesomeness make the selections for you and introduce you to wines that might soon become your new favorites.

Every wine on the Wine Awesomeness site has a 5-point rating based on prior customer reactions. This helps you find the wines your fellow subscribers liked best. 

Subscribers get a 20% discount on additional bottles. Should you fall in love with a wine from your subscription box, or simply wish to expand your home collection, you are entitled to a 20% discount on any bottles you subsequently order from the shop. Our expert reviewer found Wine Awesomeness surprisingly affordable.

Wine Awesomeness offers 3 convenient membership tiers. Depending on your needs and consumption patterns, you can choose from 3 membership options: 3, 6, or 12 bottles per month. And adventurous a la carte shoppers can enjoy a surprise with a Wine Awesomeness Mystery bottle chosen by the company’s sommeliers. 

You can also enrich your wine knowledge through its webzine, The Back Label. It's not just about drinking wine; it's about understanding and appreciating it. The Back Label features recipes, interviews with winemakers, and informative articles on its webzine. Every new issue offers an education for wine enthusiasts and novices alike. 

The pricing for these plans starts at $49 for a 3-bottle plan. This is especially reasonable given that all subscribers get free shipping.

6. Macy’s Wine Shop – A Great Choice for Discount Wines

Macy's Wine Shop delivers affordable, expertly curated wines to New Jersey. Expert sommeliers handle the curation, and the platform itself is user-friendly. Whether you're into Argentinian reds, Chilean whites, or French rosés, there's something for everyone, including a robust selection of American wines.

You'll receive 6 bottles of carefully chosen wine every 12 weeks as a Macy’s Wine Club member. Joining the wine club ensures a regular supply of excellent wines, ideal for any wine enthusiast in New Jersey who wants to keep their wine rack diverse and exciting.

Themed collections are available for specialized wine adventures. Collections like "Thrill of the Grill" or "Global Tasting Case" add an extra layer of enjoyment to your wine consumption. Martha Stewart has even curated some sets.

Gift sets are tailored to fit various budgets and occasions. You'll find sets priced under $50 and under $100, ensuring a match for different budgets. It also offers collections tailored for weddings or luxury tiers, making gift selection a breeze.

Wine Club membership provides exclusive offers. While ordering a la carte is an option, a Macy's Wine Club subscription unlocks a different level of experience. You get access to members-only wines at members-only prices.  Macy’s Wine Shop is also on our list of the best cheap wine delivery services.

Unsatisfactory wines will be replaced. The last thing you want is to be stuck with a bottle of wine you don't enjoy. Macy's Wine Club promises to replace any wine that doesn’t meet your standards. 

Pricing and shipping are tailored for convenience. Macy’s Wine Club prices start at $10.99 per bottle. What’s more, New Jersey residents receive free shipping on orders of 6 or more bottles or with a wine club membership. For all other deliveries, a flat shipping fee of $14.95 applies. 

7. Monthly Clubs Wine – Delivering Great Wine Since 1972

Monthly Clubs Wine has been delivering wine for over 50 years. It was the first wine delivery service of its kind and continues to deliver fine wines straight to your New Jersey doorstep. In a world where companies come and go, Monthly Clubs’ long track record speaks volumes.

Sommeliers choose the wines from around the globe, offering a selection of various price points. Whether your budget is modest or generous, the range of Monthly Clubs Wine options ensures that you can enjoy top-quality wines that suit your pocket. Our expert reviewer also thought it was a great choice for gifts.

You can place à la carte  orders from a selection of 65+ single-order wines each month. If a subscription isn't your style, or you're looking for something specific, you have the freedom to pick and choose. With prices ranging from $15 to $225+, you can find a wine that perfectly suits your occasion and budget.

Monthly Clubs Wine offers a full satisfaction guarantee. With its promise that "you'll never pay for a wine you don't like," you can order with confidence, knowing that your satisfaction is a priority. Owner Paul Kalemkiarnian provides his personal email address on the site and responds personally to customers.

You can also opt to pair your wine subscription with other luxury items. If wine is just one of the finer things in life you enjoy, you can pair your subscription with a beer, chocolate, cheese, cigar, or even flower club. Each subscription brings its own set of curated selections, tailored to match the quality of your wine experience.

The price for a Monthly Clubs Wine subscription starts at $20.98 per bottle.  For residents of New Jersey looking for a reliable, quality-driven wine delivery service, it offers an unbeatable combination of selection, expertise, and satisfaction.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Wine Delivery to New Jersey 

New Jersey is a diverse state, and Garden State wine drinkers have many different needs and preferences. These are the criteria that I used to determine the services that offer the best wine delivery to New Jersey.

• What’s your budget?: The wine delivery services listed here come in at a number of different price points, though each offers significant savings vs. comparable retail bottles. I found Wine Insiders offers a great selection of domestic and international wines at under $20 per bottle. 

• How much wine do you drink?: If you only finish 1 or 2 bottles a month, a monthly 6-bottle subscription will leave you with more wine than you can handle. Firstleaf offers a customizable delivery schedule that lets you order every 4, 6, 8, or 12 weeks.  

• How adventurous is your wine palate?: If you like trying new grape varietals and wines from unfamiliar regions, Wine Awesomeness offers a monthly curated subscription of wines that will expand your tasting experience with every box. 

• You can save money on bulk wine purchases: Buying in larger quantities can bring down the unit price and ensure that you have a good supply of wine you particularly fancy. Vinesse offers great value when you order in larger amounts. 

FAQ

What’s the best wine delivery to New Jersey?

Firstleaf is our pick for the best wine delivery to New Jersey. Its excellent selection of wines and the superior customer support offered by Firstleaf’s Wine Concierges put it on the top of our list. Its algorithm recommends wines you’ll love at a considerable markdown from typical retail prices.  

Can wineries ship to New Jersey? 

Wineries with a valid New Jersey Out-of-State Winery License can ship to New Jersey. All of the wineries on our list are in full compliance with New Jersey regulations and authorized to deliver wines to your Garden State home or office.  

Can I gift a wine subscription to someone in New Jersey?

So long as the recipient is over 21, you can send them a gift wine box or subscription. If you’re looking for a great gift, Vinesse offers a selection of wines for every occasion and price point.  

Best Wine Delivery to New Jersey in 2023 — Final Score